Trams face end of line in cutbacks

By Mathew Dearnaley

Council's transport committee chairman scathing of shock funding decision.

Photo / Greg Bowker
Photo / Greg Bowker

The future of Auckland's trams is on the line after a sudden decision by the council's waterfront agency to withdraw funds needed to keep them running.

The decision by Waterfront Auckland's board over the fate of Wynyard Quarter's two vintage trams and their 1.5km circuit - after just 18 months of operation - has come as a bolt from the blue for Mayor Len Brown and his transport committee chairman, Mike Lee.

Mr Lee, who headed the former Auckland Regional Council when it set aside $8 million for the initial circuit, was last night scathing of the decision, on top of a "failure of management" by the agency in delaying plans to extend the tracks to Britomart.

The decision casts grave doubt on such an extension, to which the new Auckland Council allocated a further $8.2 million.

A spokesman for the mayor said funding alternatives for waterfront trams would be considered once negotiations between the agency and their Christchurch-based operator were complete.

"A tram service between Wynyard Quarter and Britomart is still planned as part of an integrated public transport network," he told the Herald.

Waterfront Auckland chief executive John Dalzell would not comment on his board's decision, saying that would be inappropriate while he was in discussions with the operator.

Agency chairman Sir Bob Harvey could not be reached to clarify a claim by a senior source in the organisation that the board had decided to pull the plug on funding for several reasons, not just poor patronage but also perceived difficulties in integrating the trams with redevelopment plans for Daldy St through the heart of Wynyard Quarter.

Mr Lee said the picture was "a little confusing" in the absence of clear information to the council from the waterfront agency.

"It's disappointing that Waterfront Auckland, who are in and out of the council requesting support on a regular basis, haven't taken the mayor and chair of transport into their confidence," he said.

"It's not clear to me what they are doing and why - it's not a very good way for Waterfront Auckland to carry out public business, which is of great interest to the people of Auckland.

"Any talk of suspending the service is extremely disappointing given Waterfront Auckland have had two years to get on with extending the tramway to Britomart, where it will have a meaningful public transport role rather than its present role as a novelty attraction."

Mr Lee said major transport constraints were emerging in Wynyard Quarter, where the ASB Bank wants to move 1500 employees this year to its new waterfront headquarters, but where some leaseholders were indicating they did not want too many buses rumbling through the precinct.

He feared the proposed tramway extension was falling victim to squabbling between rival council organisations Waterfront Auckland and Auckland Transport - of which he is one of two council-appointed directors - over who controlled Quay St and Te Wero wharf en route to Britomart.

Latest patronage figures for the trams were unavailable yesterday from Waterfront Auckland, but they suffered a serious slump after the Rugby World Cup, when monthly patronage fell from more than 15,000 passenger trips to below 2000 in March last year, before rising to 4664 in April. But Mr Lee said he understood patronage had grown this summer.

Waterfront trams

* Two electric trams, with 52 seats and 32 seats respectively.

* 1.5km circuit of Wynyard Quarter

* Cost: $8m to set up, operating loss of $139,000 in first eight months to April.

- NZ Herald

© Copyright 2014, APN New Zealand Limited

Assembled by: (static) on production bpcf05 at 31 Oct 2014 02:03:33 Processing Time: 435ms