Pilot died from head injuries: CAA

By Tracey Roxburgh

Civil Aviation Authority safety investigator Colin Grounsell examines the wreckage of the Cessna that crashed on the Arrowtown golf course just under a year ago. Photo / James Beech
Civil Aviation Authority safety investigator Colin Grounsell examines the wreckage of the Cessna that crashed on the Arrowtown golf course just under a year ago. Photo / James Beech

The owner/pilot of a Cessna 172 Skyhawk died last year from a blunt-force head injury and severe facial fractures after his plane crashed at the Arrowtown golf course, the Civil Aviation Authority (CAA) has found.

Ian Douglas Sloan, 59, of Tauranga, was pronounced dead at the scene on October 17. His son-in-law, Wayne Candy, and aviation enthusiast Joan Urquhart sustained serious injuries in the crash, which destroyed the plane.

The CAA report, prepared by safety investigator Colin Grounsell and safety investigation manager Ben Smith, said all three were restrained with seatbelts. However, because of "rotational impact forces", the pilot was thrown to the right in his seat and the diagonal shoulder restraint "became ineffective".

"As a result, the pilot received head injuries from striking the instrument panel."

Mr Sloan, who had 315 hours' flying experience, was piloting the aircraft as it approached the private airstrip, known as Monks Strip, about 3.15pm on a return trip from Invercargill.

"As the aircraft approached Monks Strip, the passenger seated in the front right-hand seat [Mr Candy] began to video record the flight using his iPhone.

"He continued to record the remainder of the flight, including the accident sequence."

Stock on the landing area were visible on the recording, with Mr Sloan carrying out a "low pass" in an attempt to clear them, which was successful.

Moderate turbulence was encountered near the eastern end of the airstrip, along with strong crosswinds on the left.

Mr Sloan then increased engine power and altitude, flew the plane towards Arrowtown and turned around to begin an approach to land at the airstrip from the opposite direction.

The video recording showed Mr Sloan selected 20deg of wing flap on his final approach, which was high and the ground speed was also higher than "would have normally been expected".

The report said it would have been "prudent" for Mr Sloan to have conducted a "go-around rather than continue with the landing".

The aircraft touched down about 250m into the 500m airstrip, "bounced lightly twice" before settling on to the ground.

Mr Sloan increased engine power to full and conducted a take off, having "fully retracted the [wing] flap".

After the plane became airborne, he initiated a climb and left turn to avoid power lines and trees, also contending with a strong crosswind and moderate turbulence.

"The pilot continued to raise the nose of the aircraft.

"The stall warning was heard to sound in the video recording ... the aircraft then rolled rapidly to the left and pitched down as the aircraft entered a fully developed wing drop stall.

"As the aircraft rolled and pitched towards the ground, it was observed in the video recording that the pilot was holding the elevator control fully aft.

"The aircraft rapidly lost altitude and struck the ground."

The CAA concluded Mr Sloan had raised the nose of the aircraft to "an excessively high angle", but it was possible he had difficulty establishing a "true horizon" to use as a visual reference on his climb out, due to the rising terrain of the Crown Range, the report said.

"It is possible that the pilot may have been fooled by a false horizon and therefore continued to raise the aircraft's nose to establish what he perceived to be the correct climb altitude."

After the aircraft stalled, Mr Sloan's actions were "incorrect" for a recovery. "However, there was probably insufficient altitude available to ensure a safe recovery."

At the time of the accident, the aircraft was not overloaded, and its engine was in good condition.

The CAA found Mr Sloan was appropriately licensed to carry out the flight and was familiar with Monks Airstrip, having used it for take-offs and landings about 18 times since the previous February.

Moderate turbulence and crosswind conditions encountered at the time of the incident were "significant factors".

Following the incident, a CAA safety recommendation was raised to develop information for pilots regarding unsupervised operations at airstrips.

"The prudence of obtaining additional training for airstrip operations will also be highlighted."

The information would be published in the CAA Vector magazine later this year.

- Otago Daily Times

© Copyright 2014, APN New Zealand Limited

Assembled by: (static) on red akl_a2 at 15 Jul 2014 04:33:53 Processing Time: 1288ms