"There were three teams unbeaten and it came down to run rate and we ended up with bronze - a bit disappointing really," McCarty said.
"But at the last games in Wanganui [2011] we won gold."
The Hunters are mainly dairy farmers or associated industry workers so are quite used to producing liquid gold in the form of milksolids, but they are again seeking the precious metal in solid form this year.
McCarty said the team were "pretty much the same" as they were when they started masters, "although we do have four newcomers this year".
"Most of us play club cricket at home for either the Pihama or Auroa clubs."
Like some of his team mates, McCarty had also registered for other sports at the Wanganui games and medals had already come their way.
"We arrived on Sunday to play pentanque, but being the second day we weren't in the hunt for medals. But while we were at the village some of us registered for the novice table tennis played yesterday [Tuesday] and Karl Picard and I won gold,' Mccarty said.
He is also registered for euchre, Texas hold 'em and sport accuracy.
"And if there were medals going for time spent in the village tent we give that serious crack too. We've been kicked out every night since we got here, so far - at closing time, though," he said.
The Auroa Fossil Hunters were also to play the Hunterville Hackers and the Village Greenies, a Feilding side that also include players from Auckland and Palmerston North, yesterday.