The Ruapehu District Council (RDC ) had been put in a difficult position by the spillage.
"It has responsibility to provide clean, palatable water to residents.
"The options are between two rivers, one possibly tainted with blue algae and one that will contain low levels of diesel, leaving the council little choice but to return to the Makotuku in the short to medium term."
A "good" temporary solution would be for Ruapehu Alpine Lifts, as the originator of the pollution, to supply residents with appropriate under bench filtration in their homes to ensure there is no diesel contamination of their drinking and cooking water, he said. "But I doubt that will happen."
Council chief executive Peter Till, said returning to the Makotuku River for drinking water was the best option available to the community at this time.
"Council would not have returned to the Makotuku for Raetihi's water supply unless we able to meet our responsibilities to provide safe drinkable water according to government and World Health Organisation standards."
The Makara Stream could never have been a long term option as a water supply source because of its smaller size and pathway through more open farm land making, it more susceptible to run-off and algae blooms, he said.
"Over the next week as the supply in the system from the Makara is used up residents should start noticing an improvement in the taste and odour of their tap water."