A decade ago John Key's National government was taking in one billion dollars a year in revenue from tobacco taxes. The fact that three years of tobacco taxes from Maori smokers was about equal to the total of treaty settlements to Maori to date would have appealed to a banker's mind. Today tobacco tax revenue is approaching two billion.
Labour's 2021 policy is supported by National, The Greens and The Maori Party. Only ACT opposed it on the grounds that "prohibition has never worked and has unintended consequences."
Some of the "unintended consequences" have been borne by the dairy owners (20 per cent of their revenue coming from tobacco sales). I met an Indian sitting inside a caged counter in a dairy in Dannevirke this year. "Sadly sir it is necessary these days," he told me.
Another unintended consequence has been smuggling. It is estimated that one in eight packets of cigarettes is contraband and it is common to see Chinese brands on the footpaths of Auckland. In Australia, contraband cigarettes come mostly from Malaysia. ASH says New Zealand customs need more resources to fight smuggling.
New Zealand's tobacco policy has been described as "world-leading" and is the result of state-funded university research and academic grants to policy writers on a single mission.
To make us all stop smoking.
Even the public relations entity ASH is 95 per cent Government funded. Everyone is getting paid by the Government to say what they say.
The reality to date is that tobacco taxes drive up the cost of living for beneficiaries, many of whom are Maori women. It unfairly targets an ethnic group and therefore can be called racist. In the past, Tariana Turia denied that it was a racist tax because "I was the one that thought it up."
At the next election, I will be voting ACT simply because of their tobacco policy. Who knows, if they are right on this one they may be right on other things.