Into the second round, Makatea-Leylander again started with hooks, but keeping his head low left him susceptible to heavy knee strikes, while in the continued grappling action he fell twice.
Magakian threw a heavy blow to the back of the Kiwi's head, and after more knee strikes in tight, the referee again administered a standing eight count, although Makatea-Leylander had been defending as was unhurt.
Shortly afterwards, another leaping knee by Magakian rocked Makatea-Leylander back into his own corner, and although he was still defending and not hurt, the official had seen enough and waved the bout off with less than a minute remaining in the round.
Although he had never been knocked down or noticably hurt in the exchanges, as this was a IFMA event, it appeared the referee was adjudicating to a stricter standard than seen in title fights in New Zealand.
On Facebook, Makatea-Leylander was not happy with the "questionable eight counts".
"Feel robbed a bit, I was completely ok and not out-classed to call it a stoppage, didn't get to empty the tank which sucked.
"I admit I was losing, but I kept pushing the pace and trying to find some holes in his stance, but there wasn't many."
Having fought overseas for the first time, Makatea-Leylander said he was gutted he couldn't bring home the gold.
"Watching over it a couple times, it's my own fault for trying to duck my head out of the clinch, but still."