The danger was that would only exacerbate problems with keeping young people in sport and local clubs going strong which would create a domino effect through higher grades.
So a team wearing blue and white hoops was formed and allowed to play in the Manawatu competition.
And it's worked.
Firstly and most importantly it's given a place for colts-aged players to play out of Whanganui.
But it's also created a path to professional rugby for players like Te Rangatira Waitokia who was plucked from Metro to be part of the Heartland Championship winning Wanganui side and then went on to sign with Manawatu in the Mitre 10 Cup (some reward for their part in allowing Metro to exist) while players like Desmond Tyrell have juggled Metro with playing premier club rugby.
That aside, Metro have made the playoffs each year but until Saturday the title had eluded them.
Third time lucky, though, as Metro cruised to lift the trophy in their third season this year.
Hopefully what has been achieved will spur departing players to stay in the game with Whanganui clubs and encourage new players to take up the mantle.
The Metro colts story is a sports story with a universal moral. It shows what can be achieved when opportunities are created for young people to thrive.
And we need to thank people like Gibson and Malcolm for giving it to them.