''What's the message here?'' he asked. ''Airwomen going to buy this car and therefore need to be coerced by other women to do so? Or are the girls supposed to appeal to men who might buy this car?''
Other women had other roles at the Paris Motor Show. Seat employed two dancers hoisted aloft to stand on platforms balanced on a single swaying flexible pole about 10 metres in the air and grooving to a tune. The connection between Seat cars, loud music and women dancing near the ceiling is questionable. One of the judges in the Women's World Car of the Year suggested it was because Seat cars are so boring they need a bit of excitement on the stand to liven things up.
Although they tend to be few and far between, there are some enlightened motoring industry executives who consciously promote marketing to women. Paul Bucket, Public Relations Manager for Volkswagen UK, is a strong supporter of the Women's World Car of the Year concept and believes firmly in the suggestion promoted by one of America's top sales people, Tom Peters, that girls are the new boys.
''If women aren't taken into consideration by the motor industry, cars simply won't sell' he says plainly.
Tell that to the New Zealand Motoring Writers' Guild. Each year the Guild chooses its Car of the Year. Except the committee that makes up the shortlist for their Car of the Year is made up entirely of male motoring writers. In early October The Guild was approached for this story and asked why there were no women journalists on that panel. To date there has been no reply.