All were able to name the major Wairarapa waterway, the Ruamahanga River, perhaps because it is nationally recognised as one of the country's most polluted, and because it cuts through almost the entire Wairarapa valley.
When it came to the region's significant organisations, only two, Hayes and Atkinson, were able to name South Wairarapa District Council chief executive Jack Dowds.
And though Wairarapa is a farming district only Mr Atkinson knew Paul McGill was Wairarapa's Federated Farmers president.
Mr Hayes went for immediate past president Anders Crofoot and Brent Reid elevated retired Masterton District councillor Roddy McKenzie to the role.
Five of the six knew our representative rugby team wear red and green - even Dr Rotmann, who passed on two other sporting questions, saying "I don't do sport".
But when it came to women's rugby, the results were not so good.
Labour's Michael Bott and Dr McGrath knew the Eketahuna women's team were a champion side, but the others had no idea.
See if you can beat the candidates
1) Who is South Wairarapa District Council chief executive?
2) What is the name of Wairarapa's longest river?
3) Who is coach of Wairarapa United?
4) On which Carterton street is the town's new Events Centre?
5) Which is farther north, Castlepoint or Riversdale?
6) What colours do the Wairarapa-Bush rep rugby team wear?
7) Which MP represented Wairarapa from 1988 to 1999?
8) What is the children's playground in QE Park called?
9) Who is Wairarapa Federated Farmers president?
10) Which Wairarapa team won the Wellington women's rugby championship last season?
11) Who is chair of Wairarapa District Health Board?
12) Who is principal of Wairarapa College?
13) What is the name of our white kiwi?
14) Which state highway joins Featherston and Martinborough?
Answers below
Answers: Dr Jack Dowds; Ruamahanga River; Phil Keinzley; Holloway St; Castlepoint; Red and Green; Wyatt Creech; Kids Own; Paul McGill; Eketahuna; Bob Francis; Mike Schwass; Manukura; State Highway 53.