Colin James: Clear contest, clear NZ election outcome

Add a comment

John Key is a phenomenon - six years an MP and now Prime Minister. Helen Clark is a phenomenon - 15 years Labour Party leader, deputy Prime Minister at 39, nine years Prime Minister. It was quite a contest.

In the event it was a clear contest: National and friends as an alternative government to Labour and friends. And it was a clear result: a majority for that alternative government.

MMP is maturing. Voters have whittled down to a sliver the vote for parties with no hope of seats. They have now begun to whittle down the number of parties in Parliament by humiliating Winston Peters in Tauranga.

Now there are seven parties. But Peter Dunne was pushed hard this time and cannot count on another term. Jim Anderton is now in effect a small wing of Labour. So after the 2011 election - perhaps even before - there will likely be only five parties: National and Act on one side, Labour and the Greens on the other, and the Maori Party.

For the Maori Party, this was both a bad and a good result. Bad: adding only one more electorate seat and very few extra party votes after much talk of a clean sweep suggests momentum has slowed. Good: that its votes - active or by abstention - are not needed for a National-led majority in Parliament gives it room to start deal-making without the hothouse pressure of making or breaking a government.

There are big risks: getting too close to National or Labour may siphon off support. Pita Sharples said Maori and Labour are "joined at the hip", at least in Maori Party voters' minds. The real logic is a 1930s Labour-Ratana type of arrangement, linked but separate.

National needs to cut across that if it is not to face a left majority in 2011. One way of redressing its paucity of brown votes is a connection with the Maori Party. But to build a relationship will require imaginative and sensitive rethinking of Treaty of Waitangi politics, not bumper-sticker slogans.

There is another threat to the majority. The long, remarkably consistent uptrend in support from late 2002 reached high tide in mid-2008 polls. There will be a honeymoon but, given the size of the policy challenges in a credit-crunched world, that may not last long.

National has cleaned Labour out of the electorate seats in the provinces, except for Palmerston North and, possibly on specials, New Plymouth. It has pushed into the suburbs and has twice Labour's haul of electorate seats.

Electorate seats count in two ways. One is MPs' presence: two electorate offices besides the official title versus a single office and no special status for an assigned list MP.

The second is a head start if MMP is swapped for a more electorate-based system such as supplementary member, which Key wants and plans to put to voters in 2011.

But National has another foundation for longevity: its remarkable intake of able, younger MPs among the 15 new ones - the best in nearly 50 years.

Labour's outgoing achievement is its own intake of 12 new MPs, many of them young and able, with two to come yet if Clark and Michael Cullen leave Parliament as well as the leadership. That is part of Clark's legacy to the party: regeneration through candidate selections.

Phil Goff is an obvious leadership candidate. He has a wide command of portfolios, is one of Parliament's strongest debaters and is centrist.

But at some point, as the Parliament turns over to a new generation (with more women, Maori, Pasifika and Asians than last time), Labour will need its leadership to reflect that.

And the outgoing leader? Clark is highly respected offshore in a way no previous Prime Minister has been, except perhaps Peter Fraser. A top international job awaits. She may be out but she is not down. Quite the opposite.

- NZ Herald

Your views

Get the news delivered straight to your inbox

Receive the day’s news, sport and entertainment in our daily email newsletter


Have your say

1200 characters left

By and large our readers' comments are respectful and courteous. We're sure you'll fit in well.
View commenting guidelines.

© Copyright 2017, NZME. Publishing Limited

Assembled by: (static) on production apcf04 at 25 May 2017 09:17:42 Processing Time: 817ms