Suspended Labour MP Carter writes off boss

By Audrey Young

Chris Carter - photographed in Auckland last night - has expelled from Labour's ranks, but says he will stay in Parliament as MP for Te Atatu. Photo / Natalie Slade
Chris Carter - photographed in Auckland last night - has expelled from Labour's ranks, but says he will stay in Parliament as MP for Te Atatu. Photo / Natalie Slade

Suspended Labour MP Chris Carter says his view that Labour leader Phil Goff can't win the next election and should be replaced is shared by many other MPs and party activists.

"I wouldn't have acted unless I knew that virtually the entire caucus know he cannot win," Mr Carter told the Herald last night.

Mr Carter said there was a sense of optimism that Labour might have a chance of getting back into Government in a coalition if New Zealand First did well, but not with Mr Goff as Labour leader.

"It would require skills of negotiation and communication which in my view Phil hasn't got."

Several Labour MPs could do better, he said. He would not name them, but ruled out any of those newly-elected in 2008.

Mr Carter was suspended from Labour's caucus in a unanimous vote for sending an anonymous letter to press gallery offices yesterday suggesting Mr Goff's leadership was in trouble.

His party membership will be discussed by the party council in eight days, but he is facing certain expulsion, not just for being found out over the note but for his public attacks last night on Mr Goff.

Mr Carter, a minister in Helen Clark's Government, vowed to stay in Parliament as MP for Te Atatu, meaning a by-election will be avoided before the election late next year.

Mr Goff and others in Labour are questioning Mr Carter's rationality.

But Mr Carter insists that everything he wrote in the anonymous letters was true.

He appeared confident in television appearances last night and expressed no regret.

He said Mr Goff would be confronted by union-based MPs next Tuesday over his comments supporting National's plan to let employees cash in the fourth week of holiday.

"Of course it was going to happen," Mr Carter said. "It's not going to happen now, of course, but it was going to happen."

He said in the letter that the issue had "brought to a head the growing discontent in the caucus with both Goff's leadership style and his poor polling."

"David Cunliffe has a big smile on his face and many in the caucus now expect a move against Goff and [deputy Annette] King before the election," the note said.

The note also said Manurewa MP George Hawkins was being challenged by a member of the Engineers Union.

Mr Goff called a press conference at 4pm after the caucus voted to suspend Mr Carter.

"My decision to suspend Chris Carter comes just weeks after I offered him a chance to rehabilitate himself following issues around his frequent travel and excessive expenses."

He demoted Mr Carter from the front bench and the foreign affairs portfolio, but had given him the conservation portfolio and the chance to get back in the fold.

"Today there are no more chances. Chris Carter's future in the Labour caucus has come to an end."

Mr Carter said he was still "100 per cent Labour.

"I still support Labour, I just want us to have a new leader.

"Phil's a nice guy, he speaks well, he is a hard worker but he is just never going to do it."

Mr Carter said he had sent the anonymous notes "to try to start up a momentum for a leadership change."

No one else knew he was sending the letter, but its motivation and sentiment were shared by others. He did not believe the controversy would kill momentum long term.

"This will certainly not have made it go away."

Mr Carter said a lot of people in Labour thought the support base for Prime Minister John Key was more fragile than polling showed.

And the likelihood of New Zealand First leader Winston Peters entering the fray was both a danger and an opportunity.

The danger was that it would dilute the anti-National vote, affecting Labour.

But Mr Peters would also join the attack on Mr Key.

New Zealand First polled 4.5 per cent in this week's Roy Morgan poll and rumours that Wanganui Mayor Michael Laws might join New Zealand First leader Winston Peters were not denied by either of them.

In Te Atatu last night, there were mixed views and some support for Mr Carter.

Te Atatu Discount Superette owner Samir Gandhi said he and his family would always support the MP.

"I voted for him and I support Carter, because he's Labour."

Te Atatu resident Lesley Rientsma said she supported the MP because of his work within the community.

"He's done so much good in the community and I think that's great. He's a good man. However I must admit he's fallen off the rails a bit lately and this last plot business is a bit bizarre.

"But if we were to have a by-election, I'd vote for him."


Chris Carter was seen by parliamentary staff hand-delivering letters to the mailroom at Parliament yesterday in air mail envelopes marked "Office of Minister of Finance, New Zealand".

The envelopes, with handwritten addresses, were delivered in the morning to the boxes of the Herald, Radio New Zealand, the Dominion Post, TV One and TV3.

Reporters contacted Labour about the contents - alleging strife over Phil Goff's leadership and a challenge to George Hawkins in Manurewa.

Labour was told Mr Carter had been seen at the mailroom.

Mr Goff flew back to Wellington from Auckland, and a check by party whip Darren Hughes showed the handwriting on the envelopes matched that from a book Mr Carter used when he was senior whip.

Mr Goff, deputy leader Annette King and Mr Hughes confronted Mr Carter, who initially denied writing the letters. He confessed when confronted with the evidence and Mr Goff told him he would be moving his suspension.

Mr Hughes got the seven signatures required for a special caucus and MPs met at 3.30pm.

Mr Carter was invited but did not attend. The vote to suspend him was unanimous.

Labour's New Zealand Council will consider his future on August 7.

- NZ Herald

Get the news delivered straight to your inbox

Receive the day’s news, sport and entertainment in our daily email newsletter


© Copyright 2017, NZME. Publishing Limited

Assembled by: (static) on production apcf04 at 23 May 2017 04:41:26 Processing Time: 738ms