Church outrage as cartoon to air tonight

By Errol Kiong, Martin Johnston

A row between Catholics and media firm CanWest has escalated with the controversial "Bloody Mary" episode of South Park screening on television tonight, weeks ahead of schedule.

The Catholic Church says the move is "provocative and inflammatory".

At least one advertiser has pulled its advertising from CanWest's radio stations. The move by CanWest to screen the episode seven weeks early follows an open letter from seven bishops on Sunday urging Catholics to boycott TV3's news and advertisers should the company go ahead with the screening on its sister channel, C4.

The church's communications director, Lyndsay Freer, said she was handed a press release at 5pm yesterday announcing the decision to run the episode today, and was asked to comment for the 6pm news.

Being ambushed with the release and asked for immediate comment was cynical. "It was an incredibly arrogant, unethical and inflammatory thing to do."

Mrs Freer will lodge a complaint with the Broadcasting Standards Authority about TV3 "setting her up".

She said the South Park episode, which shows a statue of the Virgin Mary spurting blood at the Pope, is offensive to Catholics, people of other faiths and women in general.

"CanWest justifies screening the episode by calling it satirical comment. What point is made by associating the Virgin Mary with rectal and menstrual bleeding which hits a cardinal and, I think, the Pope, in the face?"

Mrs Freer branded the move "provocative and inflammatory".

"While we think that freedom of the press is absolute in one sense, whether it's satire or not, it's still governed by broadcasting standards.

"Whatever the genre, there are still standards of decency and good taste."

Patrick Quin, owner of the recruitment agency Max Recruitment, said he had withdrawn advertising worth about $6500 a month excluding GST from CanWest in protest at the decision to broadcast the episode.

"I just think it's grubby," said Mr Quin, who described himself as a non-practising Catholic.

He said a CanWest manager phoned him yesterday to discuss his move and told him that not many other advertisers had pulled their ads.

CanWest said it was bringing the episode forward to 9.30 tonight in response to high levels of debate.

South Park usually draws about 30,000 viewers.

"Given that by far the majority of those involved in the debate have not had the opportunity to view the episode, we feel it is important to give the public of New Zealand that chance," said Rick Friesen, chief operating officer of CanWest-owned TVWorks.

"I strongly believe once people see this programme in the context of the entire episode, many New Zealanders will wonder what all the fuss was about."

He was confident the episode would meet the requirement of the Television Code approved by the authority.

"We also acknowledge that some viewers may not enjoy this episode. I would encourage any viewers who feel they may not appreciate its style of humour to act with their remote, and not watch the programme."

But former Archbishop of Wellington Cardinal Tom Williams said it was an "opportunistic" move.

"I don't believe that 'offensive' can be condoned whether in the name of entertainment or anything else."

Media buyer Martin Gillman, chief executive of Total Media, said the publicity would boost viewership of the episode, but it would still be small.

"CanWest don't stand to gain financially from this because the advertising will already have been sold a long time ago."

Prime Minister Helen Clark has said the episode sounds revolting.

A spokesman for the Catholic group Family Life International, Brendan Malone, said a website promoting a boycott of CanWest advertisers had recorded 800 registrations.

© Copyright 2014, APN New Zealand Limited

Assembled by: (static) on production apcf05 at 20 Dec 2014 13:16:36 Processing Time: 775ms