Isaac Davison

Isaac Davison is a NZ Herald political reporter.

Bowel screening diagnose cancer with no symptoms

Health Minister Tony Ryall said bowel screenings had led to a diagnosis of cancer in people who had no symptoms. Photo / Mark Mitchell
Health Minister Tony Ryall said bowel screenings had led to a diagnosis of cancer in people who had no symptoms. Photo / Mark Mitchell

The early detection of 129 bowel cancer cases in a pilot screening programme makes a compelling case for an urgent nationwide roll-out, lobby groups say, but officials are wary of creating insurmountable waiting lists for examinations.

Health Minister Tony Ryall published an update of the $24 million trial at the Waitemata District Health Board , saying the bowel screenings had led to a diagnosis of cancer in people who had no symptoms.

The scheme invited 50-74-year-olds to provide a sample to the DHB. If the sample showed any symptoms, they had a colonoscopy.

The trial data will help Government decide whether to introduce a bowel screening programme at all DHBs. Bowel cancer kills around 2700 New Zealanders a year.
Beat Bowel Cancer spokeswoman Megan Smith said the preliminary results made a strong case for expanding the pilot into a national scheme before the four-year trial ended.


"When you see ... that Waitemata has a below-average incidence of bowel cancer in New Zealand we would say it is time to get on with rolling out a national pilot so that more lives can be saved that at the moment are being lost needlessly early."

The previous Labour Government announced a nationwide screening programme to begin in 2009 but this stalled after National came into power.

Mr Ryall said yesterday it was important to collect evidence on whether the programme was cost-effective. This would be known by mid-2016.

One of the issues has been the need for extra staff to perform the higher numbers of colonoscopies which would result from an expanded screening programme.

Nadine Hooper fitted into few of the risk categories when she took her first bowel cancer screening test two years ago.

After the test detected some symptoms, healthcare professionals told the 46 year-old that it was unlikely they were a sign of something sinister.


The mother-of-two from Papamoa said: "Even as I got on the table for the colonoscopy the specialist said 'What are you concerned about?"'

However, the doctor found a single cancerous polyp.

"It totally came out of the blue," Ms Hooper said. "I've got no family history of bowel cancer. I'm female, I'm technically too young to have it."

"I wasn't really on anyone's radar for having bowel cancer."

Ms Hooper, a relief teacher, was now urging friends and family to get tested. She said that in hindsight, she had noticed gradual changes in her body and was lucky that she was tested in time.

She still faced a difficult four-month wait between her initial test and a colonoscopy - a sign of district health boards' struggle to keep up with the demand for examinations.

Patients who opted for a private colonoscopy could expect a bill of around $1400.

Ms Hooper strongly supported a national bowel cancer screening programme, arguing that the increased funding would far outweigh the emotional toll of New Zealand's abnormally high number of bowel cancer cases.

Screening programmes tended to detect cancers at an earlier stage than a normal clinical setting, in which people only visited their doctor once they become aware of physical symptoms.

- NZ Herald

© Copyright 2014, APN New Zealand Limited

Assembled by: (static) on production bpcf05 at 28 Dec 2014 10:58:46 Processing Time: 421ms