"For a young man at 19, I salute him for being in that position, although he does not want to be mayor."
Although Ron Wilkins was still undecided.
"I think it's between either Sandra and Bayden; both came across with valuable things."
Marie Dunningham believed "Waitawhara won the debate in terms of speaking, but he didn't win the argument."
"I can't decide between Sandra, Simon and Bayden. Not one was outstanding," Ms Dunningham said.
A Hastings local, who did not wished to be named, was also in agreement.
"Either Sandra or Simon. They spoke clearly and had good background knowledge. They were also reflective of what has happened in the past.
He said he would wait until the day to make up his mind on who to vote for, but thought "Hastings was in good hands."
Another woman, who did not want her name published, believed Stuart Perry was the right man for the job, despite no one standing out for her.
Another in attendance, Darren Davies, said the candidates all "did a good job, but Stuart particularly had a good business approach."
Jan Chisum said there was "a lot" to think about. "I am pleased I came. No one outshone anyone - maybe in promises they did."