Adam Bennett

Adam is a political reporter for the New Zealand Herald.

Navy dispatched over oil dispute

The seismic survey vessel Orient Explorer bears down on Greenpeace inflatables attempting to force the ship off course. Photo / Greenpeace
The seismic survey vessel Orient Explorer bears down on Greenpeace inflatables attempting to force the ship off course. Photo / Greenpeace

The police have the legal power to prevent Greenpeace protesters from disrupting Petrobras gas exploration vessel Orient Explorer's work off East Cape and have already dispatched a naval vessel to the area, Prime Minister John Key has confirmed.

Mr Key said he last night received an opinion from Crown Law that the police did have jurisdiction to uphold New Zealand law in the Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) which lies from 12 to 200 nautical miles offshore.

"My expectations are that the police would balance the rights of people to peacefully protest also with the rights of the company to carry out the seismic activity in Raukumara Basin that we granted them as a Government.

"How they balance those rights on the high seas is clearly an operational matter for police."

The Herald understands the vessel deployed is the inshore patrol ship the HMNZS Pukaki.

Mr Key said he understood that under a long standing agreement the police could deploy naval vessels and other assets as required to uphold New Zealand's rule of law at sea as required.

"It's also my understanding that has occurred and that there is now a navy boat in the region."

But although Petrobras executives were reportedly reduced to tears after meeting with East Coast locals opposed to their work, Mr Key says the Government has not been asked by the giant Brazilian company to intervene.

Recent days have seen swimmers from a protest flotilla of five vessels forcing Petrobras' seismic survey vessel Orient Explorer off course in the Raukumara Basin, off the East Cape, and disrupting its work.

The Government's willingness to act to stop protestors from hindering Petrobras' search for oil and gas off the East Cape shows their priorities, Green Party MP Gareth Hughes said.

While the Government is looking to send out the Navy to help a foreign oil company, Hughes said it would not do the same during the last Japanese whaling season in the Southern Ocean.

"I guess it shows their priorities - they're happy to stand on the sidelines over whaling but then explore any options possible to protect foreign interests," he said.

Hughes said last year he repeatedly asked questions in the House over sending a vessel to the Southern Ocean to observe tensions between whaling vessels and protest ships, but the Government refused.

He said the level of opposition to deep sea oil drilling in New Zealand was similar to Kiwis' opposition to whaling.

"They are concerned New Zealand doesn't have the capacity to deal with a Deepwater Horizon disaster," Hughes said, referring to the large spill in the Gulf of Mexico last year.

"Going down this path has double risks - the risk to our clean green brand which is worth billions of dollars and the actual risk of an oil spill."

Mr Key yesterday said his Government respected people's right to protest, "but we also respect the rights of other people to carry out legal activities like Petrobras is".

The police and their minister Judith Collins were exploring "all of their options" with regards to the protest and Mr Key said sending a naval patrol vessel "could be" one of those options.

However, given the area in which the exploration lies in New Zealand's exclusive economic zone - which lies from 12 to 200 nautical miles offshore - it was unclear what the police and Government's powers were.

Ms Collins had asked officials from Crown Law to clarify that.

Mr Key said the Government had done that "off its own bat" and a spokesman for Acting Energy and Resources Minister Hekia Parata confirmed Petrobras had not asked the Government to look into the issue.

Meanwhile, an airforce Orion aircraft had also been dispatched to the area on an "observation" basis.

Police Superintendent Barry Taylor told National Radio the aircraft had been dispatched at the request of the police, but he was not aware that police had received a complaint from Petrobras about the protests.

Police powers outside the 12-mile territorial limit were the same as under New Zealand law, he said, though police were also exploring legal options.

The Green Party yesterday said it wanted an end to deepwater exploration in New Zealand waters, including Petrobras' current seismic survey, until there were assurances that a blowout and oil spill similar to the Deepwater Horizon catastrophe in the Gulf of Mexico last year could be swiftly dealt with.

Labour's energy and resources spokesman, Charles Chauvel, said his party opposed granting licences for deepwater exploration in the absence of environmental protections.

Mr Key said the Government was conscious of environmental issues and "we are in the process of introducing legislation that will address environmental concerns for deep sea wells".

"It is the Government's view that we can balance those environmental concerns with the desire of a great many New Zealanders to create better jobs and better incomes."

Greenpeace climate campaigner Simon Boxer said given there was no environmental protection framework for the area to be explored at the time the Government granted Petrobras the licence, his organisation did not believe the exploration work itself was legal.

"We believe the permit process is flawed from the very beginning and the Government has not done due process on this," he said. "If they want to take us to court we're more than happy to attend and be prosecuted. We believe they won't do that because it will actually be an opportunity to put all these international and national issues before a judge and they would run the risk of losing that court case."

Meanwhile, Ani Pahuru-Huriwai, of protest group Ahi Kaa, told the Herald she had helped organise a meeting on Sunday between Petrobras executives and representatives from protest groups and iwi Te Whanau a Apanui and Ngati Porou.

The executives were not accorded the powhiri and other honours at Te Araroa's Hine Rupe Marae which visitors might otherwise expect.

Ms Pahuru-Huriwai confirmed two of the Petrobras executives began crying during the meeting when faced with the strong opposition. She said the executives talked about their workplan, their commitment to environmental protection and financial capacity.

"We weren't interested because it's not about money, it's mana and our ability to feed our families from our traditional 'supermarket'."

WHO'S IN CHARGE

* Petrobras is searching for oil and gas in New Zealand's exclusive economic zone - from 12 to 200 nautical miles offshore.

* Protesters are blocking the work.

* Government has asked Crown Law to clarify legal options in that zone, including whether the Navy could be called in.

* Police say their powers outside the 12-mile territorial limit are the same as under New Zealand law - but are also exploring legal options.

* Protesters say the search is illegal.

Your views

© Copyright 2014, APN New Zealand Limited

Assembled by: (static) on production apcf03 at 28 Nov 2014 07:40:31 Processing Time: 480ms