Chris Rattue is a sports columnist for the New Zealand Herald.

All Blacks player ratings: Dagg back to his best

Chris Rattue runs the rule over the standout players in the All Blacks' 46-6 win over Wales in Dunedin last night.

New Zealand

Israel Dagg 9
Errors crept in but a tremendous test full of running. Huge part in Moala try.

Ben Smith 8
Great try finish in the corner, sparkling runs. Ended up in the centres.

George Moala 7
Strong running led the breaking of Wales but didn't link well, one poor kick and stuffed up a try.

Ryan Crotty 7
Often in harmony, never the soloist. Busy test and hauled down Roberts to prevent try.

Julian Savea 6
Started by spilling a long Welsh kick and couldn't find the party. Didn't justify recall.

Beauden Barrett 9
Poor Wales were no match for Barrett's whirling legs. Two terrific tries, and also goal kicked well. Even a charge down. Shifted to fullback.

Aaron Smith 9
The commanding live wire. Big passes created tries. Pinpoint bombs. Candidate as NZ's greatest halfback, ever.

Kieran Read 8
Led the defence including series of outstanding lunging tackles. Not so much with the ball.

Sam Cane 7
Marked down here for rash of penalties/yellow card, but strong game all over the park.

Elliot Dixon 5
Quiet debut. Largely anonymous and lost the ball on one of his few runs.

Brodie Retallick 8
Couldn't keep him out of the game. One dropped ball. Patchell certainly felt a tackle.

Sam Whitelock 7
Kick off receptions but not huge involvement or stellar moment.

Charlie Faumuina 7
Owen Franks lives. No ball running, which is his trademark. Scrummed and tackled well instead.

Dane Coles 8
Got to love his free range style. Loads of tackles, fine grab and gap run for try, one wonky throw.

Joe Moody 7
Produced one of the great scrum sights ever, popping Francis onto the Welsh pack.


Codie Taylor (Coles, 71m) 5
Token appearance as match deteriorated at the end.

Wyatt Crockett (Moody, 52m) 6
Lacked usual impact. One amazing turnover. Scrum maintained clear edge.

Ofa Tu'ungafasi (Faumuina, 52m) 5
Anonymous around the field. Scrum worked pretty well.

Luke Romano (Retallick, 65m) 5
A couple of familiar barges, little else.

Liam Squire (Dixon, 54m) 8
Storming test intro. Three big runs, big part in Coles try and hunted in defence.

Tawera Kerr-Barlow (A. Smith, 71m) 5
The trouble is, nothing compares to Aaron Smith.

Lima Sopoaga (Crotty, 54m) 6
Sharp hands except when he had a try chance unfortunately.

Waisake Naholo (Moala, 48m) 5
A centre? One fine turnover, some runs, but the mistakes keep coming.

New Zealand All Blacks perform the haka during the third test. Photo / Brett Phibbs.
New Zealand All Blacks perform the haka during the third test. Photo / Brett Phibbs.


Rhys Patchell 5
A try saving tackle on Ben Smith but generally frail and Dagg ran around him.

Liam Williams 9
Stunning defensive moments and brilliant turnover in over-run side. Ran bravely without getting far. Terrific series.

Jonathan Davies 5
Tackle misses including big one on Moala.

Jamie Roberts 5
Midfield carthorse ploughed through Coles and Cane in Wales' best attacking moment. Little else.

Hallam Amos 4
A stop gap not up to this level. Couldn't stop Smith try, skinned by Barrett for another.

Dan Biggar 5
Bumped early by Savea, missed Barrett on try run. Looked a bit gun shy this time.

Rhys Webb 6
Tough job behind struggling pack, couple of battling runs..first test remains the highlight.

Taulupe Faletau 6
Got hold of the ball but went sideways or nowhere. Too much ball carrying hope on his shoulders.

Sam Warburton 5
Little inspiration from the well respected captain.

Ross Moriarty 6
Ditto the previous tests. Has the heart, but other muscles need pumping up.

Alun Wyn Jones 6
One excellent late offload, not a lot else.

Luke Charteris 6
Put himself about as they say without doing much damage.

Tomas Francis 5
Popped skywards in infamous scrum moment, but came back well in one defensive scrum.

Ken Owens 8
Put in a top shift around field and tried to take the game to All Blacks. Even tackled Barrett.

Rob Evans 7
Decent game but as general front row comment, Wales needs more scrum power.


Scott Baldwin (Owens, 56m) 4
No impact, or much else.

Aaron Jarvis (Evans, 46m) 5
Solid effort when Wales needed spectacular work from somewhere.

Samson Lee (Francis, 46m) 4
Looks more like a starting prop.

Jake Ball (Charteris, 59m) 6
Along with Davies, the reserve who tried to make a difference. Some strong carries.

Ellis Jenkins (Warburton, 69m) 4
A tough debut series.

Gareth Davies (Webb, 54m) 6
Ran in right direction, didn't give much direction. A tough ask with game already gone.

Rhys Priestland (Biggar, 58m) 4
Nothing of note as game crawled to messy end.

Scott Williams (Roberts, 53m) 5
Earlier than expected chance. Clean defence, little threat.

Get the news delivered straight to your inbox

Receive the day’s news, sport and entertainment in our daily email newsletter

Stats provided by

© Copyright 2016, NZME. Publishing Limited

Assembled by: (static) on production apcf03 at 22 Oct 2016 09:08:44 Processing Time: 829ms