Chris Rattue runs the rule over the standout players in the All Blacks' 39-21 win over Wales at Eden Park last night.

Ben Smith 7
Unusual amount of things went wrong. Scintillating return to create try. Shifted to wing and could stay there.

Waisake Naholo 6
A hero/zero night. More Hyde than Jekyll unfortunately but vital cannon ball try. Got involved.

Malakai Fekitoa 6
Still finding his feet. Failed to nail his one try chance when Webb grasped him. Top hit on Roberts.

Advertisement

Ryan Crotty 5
Ordinary by the best No. 12 standards, and always will be. North turned him into doormat late.

Julian Savea 4
The Bus was a passenger. Poor touchline defence. Hooked early. Try leap but should be grounded.

Aaron Cruden 7
Like a lot of players, a mixed bag and goal kicking still unconvincing. Top moments and started to hum.

Aaron Smith 7
Scruffy game at times and struggled to find his flow. Sniped through the middle well as All Blacks got on top.

Kieran Read 8
Terrific overall...the works burger. One great hit on Roberts. Captaincy survived a moderate test.

Sam Cane 5
Nondescript. Seemed to play as a link man. Huge boots to fill, loud footsteps behind him.

Jerome Kaino 7
Crunching test in the trenches. The World Cup star remains the pack iron man.

Brodie Retallick 8
Worth a 9 but for big missed tackle on Liam Williams. Huge motor. Blossomed on attack.

Luke Romano 7
Also missed Liam Williams, but amongst the first half best with lots of muscular charges.

Owen Franks 6
Led the tidiest scrums in test history. Not much else.

Dane Coles 8
Brilliant lineout throwing vital. Lots of tackles. No trademark magic moment.

Joe Moody 6
Ditto for Franks in scrum stalemate. Has more to give with the ball.

Reserves

Nathan Harris (Coles, 71m) 5

Clung on to ball for a try.

Wyatt Crockett (Moody, 48m) 7
A stunning offload, and decent impact.

Charlie Faumuina (Franks, 45m) 6
Not enough ball running.

Patrick Tuipulotu (Romano, 52m) 7
Lineout steal and feed for Read try helped secure the win.

Ardie Savea (Cane, 60m) 7
The power surge. Get ready for the Cane v Savea debate.

TJ Perenara (A. Smith, 68m) 5
Had try rubbed out and one ponderous pass.

Beauden Barrett (J. Savea, 42m) 7
Twinkle toes made a difference. Fullback start calls.

Seta Tamanivalu (Fekitoa, 74m) 6
Looked quite likely on limited chance.

Watch: Herald rugby writers Gregor Paul and Pat McKendry discuss last night's All Blacks win.

Herald rugby writers Gregor Paul and Pat McKendry comment on the All Blacks first test performance against Wales.

Read more:

Wales

Liam Williams 8

Fabulous running - went for gaps and found a few. Created the Webb try. Ended up hobbling.

George North 8
Some errors but the big man was a constant threat going past and through defenders.

Jonathan Davies 6
The midfield monsters did an okay job but a bit more craft wouldn't go amiss.

Jamie Roberts 6
Part of the Red Wall. Ditto for Davies.

Hallam Amos 5
Neat work to create first try but looked out of his depth after that.

Dan Biggar 7
Stood up to a physical pounding, ran the show pretty well, one miracle mark...goalkicking a bit off.

Rhys Webb 8
One of the stars of the show. Got Wales into the fight, clever touches.

Taulupe Faletau 7
Decent test, plenty of tackles, but key strike weapon needed to do more with the ball if Wales were to upset.

Sam Warburton 6
Not a great night for the starting openside flankers. Scrapped away.

Ross Moriarty 7
One of the best workers in the test without setting the world on fire.

Alun Wyn Jones 5
Got his hands on the ball but static and no lineout attack.

Bradley Davies 5
Hard to spot.

Samson Lee 6
Solid test - Welsh scrum was solid.

Ken Owens 6
Vigorous game but lineout wasn't 100 per cent.

Gethin Jenkins 7
The veteran flung himself into the game, scrum solid, nailed Cruden.

Reserves
Scott Baldwin (Owens, 64m) 5
One lineout lost.

Rob Evans (Jenkins, 64m) 6
Got involved but low impact and dropped ruck ball near All Blacks goal line.

Tomas Francis (Lee, 71m) 5
Token change.

Jake Ball (B.Davies, 71m) 4
Also got an earlier chance when Jones had concussion check. Zero impact.

Ellis Jenkins (Warburton, 71m) 5
Hard to impress on debut with Wales holding their bench back.

Gareth Davies (Webb, 71m) 5
Only needed when impressive Webb tired.

Gareth Anscombe (Williams, 64m) 4
Not a glorious return to Eden Park. Is he test class? Jury still out.

Scott Williams (Roberts, 64m) 4
Wales lost the battle of the bench.