"He said it took a man to apologise. He said it is an emotional game and not to worry about it.
"My dad has always brought me up to respect people but, if you have opinions and if you are in the right, don't be afraid to say so."
Tonight, Shelvey is likely to take his place in the Liverpool midfield in another game in which pulling out of tackles will not be an option: the Merseyside derby, a fixture that has seen more red cards than any other in the Premier League.
Peter Reid, who held Everton's midfield together when Merseyside derbies settled championships rather than local pride, laments that the art of the tackle has gone. Shelvey agrees.
"You have got to be very careful what you do and what you say nowadays," he said. "Football is becoming less and less of a contact sport. Some players are making what you would consider good, old-fashioned tackles but are being punished for them.
"You can't get away with anything. It's a joke, to be honest. How can you pull out of a tackle if the ball is there to be won? That's what fans want to see but times have changed and we have to adapt. You don't go on the training pitch and learn how to tackle. You learn how to shoot, how to pass but not how to tackle."
Shelvey is the kind of young footballer England should be producing: intelligent, articulate and talented. However, his journey to Liverpool's first team demonstrates the path is never straightforward. He grew up in Romford, where London blurs into Essex. He first joined Arsenal but fell out with the manager of the under-10 side. The young Shelvey did not appreciate the rule that missed goals meant 10 press-ups.
"I don't even do 10 press-ups now," he smiled.
"Then I went to West Ham, where my brother was. When you were in the younger age group you would play four 20-minute games on a Sunday afternoon and the favoured players would play all four 20s and the less favoured ones would play two 20s. My brother was two years above me and he was playing just two games and I was often in all four. My dad was a coach at West Ham at the time and he thought that was wrong.
"We brought my brother out and my dad left but he said if I wanted to stay at West Ham, he would support me. It was hard because West Ham was our club. [Paolo] Di Canio, [Joe] Cole and [Michael] Carrick were all there and Glenn Roeder was the manager.
"He pulled me into his office and tried to make me stay but I said no. I wanted to stick with my brother because he was so upset. I spent a year playing locally and joined Charlton."
At The Valley, Shelvey became, at 16 years and 59 days, the youngest player ever to appear for Charlton, beating the record set by Paul Konchesky, who would also end up at Anfield, albeit less successfully.
It says something for the state of Liverpool that Brendan Rodgers is the fourth manager Shelvey has dealt with in two years. The Ulsterman, however, surely has more small talk than his first, Rafa Benitez.
"Rafa was here when I came but I believe Kenny Dalglish had a big part in my signing," he said.
Curiously, although Dalglish was the one who scouted him, Shelvey felt let down when he was under him.
"I didn't think I was given a fair chance under Kenny," he said. "The night before we played in the League Cup at Brighton, I thought: 'Well, if I'm not even going to play in the cup games, then I'm not going to play in any of them.' I went in and just asked him if I could go on loan. He said yes but added that he wouldn't let me go to a club that didn't suit me."
The club Dalglish chose was Blackpool, where Ian Holloway's brand of attacking football was not so dissimilar to that favoured by Rodgers, albeit with more of a forward threat. It worked out magnificently.
"Even if you had a bad game, you knew you would probably be playing next week and as a young footballer, that is what you want," said Shelvey. "The players also had to wash their own kit. I didn't," he smiled. "My girlfriend did."
England internationals, however, don't have to shop for washing powder and, after his appearance as a substitute in the World Cup qualifier against San Marino on October 12, that is what Shelvey is.
"I thought nobody would talk to me," said Shelvey. "I'd gone very quickly from playing in a park with my mates to sitting next to Wayne Rooney at dinner."
The ice was broken by Manchester United's Danny Welbeck. "He pulled me when I arrived and shouted: 'Leave my manager alone!"'
- The Independent