Adam Bennett

Adam is a political reporter for the New Zealand Herald.

Urgent hearing for Treaty bid to block asset sales

Opposition to the Government's partial asset sales policy moves today from public protest to a Lower Hutt marae. Photo / APN
Opposition to the Government's partial asset sales policy moves today from public protest to a Lower Hutt marae. Photo / APN

An urgent Waitangi Tribunal hearing which Prime Minister John Key acknowledges could delay his flagship asset sales programme begins in Wellington today.

After passing the necessary legislation last month, the Government plans to begin its "mixed-ownership model" partial asset sales programme by selling up to 49 per cent of shares in Mighty River Power by November.

But in a hearing starting this morning at Waiwhetu Marae in Lower Hutt, the tribunal is urgently hearing two claims brought on behalf of Maori Council chairman Sir Graham Latimer, the council itself and 11 others.

The claimants are seeking a recommendation from the tribunal that the asset sales programme be put on hold until the underlying claims are dealt with.

They also want a recommendation that the Resource Management Act and other relevant legislation be amended to give Maori more control over the resources and to provide compensation for their past and future use.

When the Mixed Ownership Model Act was passed late last month, Mr Key acknowledged the Maori Council's litigation posed a risk to the timetable for the Mighty River sale.

"That's always a possibility that could slow up the process," he said.

"The Government's view is that there's not merit to any litigation and that the issues of water which sit at the heart of any potential litigation have been well and truly covered through lots of other things we're doing, but I'm simply saying there's always a risk."

The Government is negotiating with the Iwi Leaders Forum over Maori rights and interests in freshwater.

But in its statement of claim, the Maori Council says the forum is not speaking on behalf of all Maori and the negotiations are taking place before all relevant Treaty claims have been heard.

State Owned Enterprises Minister Tony Ryall has said the Crown would cite the Ika Whenua case in 1990s, when the Appeal Court denied a bid to block a Government plan to transfer dams to energy companies because Maori rights would not be diminished.

THE CLAIMS

Wai 2357

Argues that partial privatisation of Mighty River, Meridian Energy and Genesis Energy would prevent Maori with valid but yet-to-be-determined claims over freshwater and geothermal resources from receiving stakes in the power companies as redress.

Wai 2358

Argues Crown actions and policies on freshwater and geothermal resources have breached the Treaty by using common law to alienate Maori from the resources. It also contends legislation such as the Resource Management Act does not adequately recognise Maori interests in those resources, and that Treaty policy doesn't provide adequate redress, such as compensation, or strong legal rights for Maori.

- NZ Herald

© Copyright 2014, APN New Zealand Limited

Assembled by: (static) on production apcf05 at 25 Oct 2014 05:42:38 Processing Time: 489ms