John Armstrong 's Opinion

John Armstrong is the Herald's chief political commentator

John Armstong: Labour must think laterally to win war

77 comments
Cosgrove's triumph in anti-privatisation fight not enough

Clayton Cosgrove has been fixated on the woes of Solid Energy. Photo / Duncan Brown
Clayton Cosgrove has been fixated on the woes of Solid Energy. Photo / Duncan Brown

Game and set to Labour ... but not match. Not yet anyway. When it comes to dealing with Labour's enemies - or as he would prefer to say - dealing to them, Clayton Cosgrove displays all the sympathy and mercy of a knuckleduster-carrying rottweiler.

As far as the Christchurch list MP is concerned, there can only be two outcomes on the battlefield of political life - either making sure you win, or making damn sure you don't lose.

Having joined the party at the age of 14, he is tribal Labour to the core - like his mentor, Mike Moore.

That connection never endeared him to Helen Clark or her followers who saw his preference for rough-and-tumble politics as challenging their more intellectual approach.

Like John Tamihere, Cosgrove's audience is the shrinking class of conservative male, blue-collar workers whose attachment to Labour has become weak or non-existent.

It is an audience that responds to language which calls a spade a spade. It is the language of an angry segment of the population. It is the language of opposition.

Cosgrove consequently sounds as happy, if not happier, in opposition as in government.

Indeed, he remains an unreconstructed Opposition politician. He views National as comprising an unholy alliance of New Zealand's privileged landed gentry, Neanderthal-like Hooray Henrys and latter-day gangsters who would sell the country's birthright for a couple of shekels.

He has thus been a perfect fit for the role of Labour's spokesman on state-owned enterprises (SOEs). His anti-privatisation rhetoric has fuelled the party's campaign against the float of up to 49 per cent of each of the three remaining electricity generators, Mighty River Power, Meridian Energy and Genesis Energy.

Everything has changed, however, with the Supreme Court chucking out the Maori Council's bid to halt the partial asset sales. The court's unanimity gave the green light for the first share offer to proceed. The public debate has likewise moved on.

The big question is whether Cosgrove can move along with it. The debate is now about whether the shares will be a good investment. It is about whether the Government's retention of 51 per cent of the shares in each power generator is purely cosmetic when it comes to ministers exercising some control over the new "mixed ownership model" companies.

Cosgrove, however, has been fixated on the woes of Solid Energy. That is understandable. It was his persistence - and his alone - that forced the Government to buckle and agree that the state coal company's former chief executive, Don Elder, should be "invited" to appear at Thursday's meeting of Parliament's commerce committee.

National quickly sought to dispel surmise about what Elder might have to say about the SOE's plunge into the red last year and why it now had a debt burden of big enough for the company's bankers to be called in.

The Prime Minister revealed he and other senior ministers had been pretty much at loggerheads with Solid Energy's board for the past 18 months, most notably over the company's need for capital for its since-scrapped diversification programme.

At the same time, John Key also tried to put some distance between National and Solid Energy's spiral into indebtedness to the tune of close to $390 million.

National was not interested in "pointing fingers" over who was to blame for that. The Government was instead focused on the company's future.

But Labour had obtained some embarrassing Cabinet papers under the Official Information Act. These showed that in 2009 Cabinet ministers had told Solid Energy and other state-owned enterprises to increase their gearing - the ratio of their borrowing to their equity.

The purpose of this exercise was to force Solid Energy to lift its profitability so it could pay higher dividends to a cash-strapped Government.

Solid Energy's gearing jumped from less than 10 per cent in 2008 - the year National won office - to nearly 42 per cent last year.

Unfortunately for Key, Labour found some quotes from him last month pointing his finger at high gearing as one of the factors responsible for Solid Energy's financial predicament.

In short, game and set to Labour ... but not match. Not yet anyway.

Cosgrove and his colleagues might have smacked Key around the ears. That will not worry the Prime Minister. His priority is the Mighty River Power float. Given it is too late to halt that sale, Labour's priority is to bring enough public pressure to bear on the following floats of Meridian and Genesis so they are either cancelled or prove to be relative failures and discredit the whole asset sales programme. It is difficult to see how a formal inquiry which Cosgrove is demanding - and which National would block - helps Labour in that regard.

Admittedly, an ongoing inquiry could keep Solid Energy in the news. It would serve as a platform to highlight the fact that the company was also on the list of upcoming share floats until it started to rapidly go down the gurgler. That serves as a cautionary warning to would-be investors that the mixed ownership model is not immune from financial risk. Those who bought shares in the then state-owned Bank of New Zealand in the late 1980s got badly burned.

Labour, however, has made little if anything of this potentially lucrative line of attack. With that in mind, Labour should be targeting the nearly 330,000 people who have pre-registered for Mighty River Power shares rather than preaching to the converted - the 392,000 people who signed the petition seeking a referendum on partial asset sales which National will anyway ignore.

Labour also needs to get the message across that the mixed-ownership model companies will not be a simple adaptation of the state-owned enterprise model.

The Treasury has been transparent in saying that despite retaining a majority shareholding, the Government will be trading off ministerial oversight for greater commercial discipline. The absence of statements of corporate intent will reduce ministers' ability to influence company strategy.

The Government's primary tool for "protecting its investment" - as the Treasury puts it - will be the appointment of suitably qualified directors.

Under the Companies Act - which will govern how these new companies function - those directors will be obliged to act in what they believe to be the best interests of the company, rather than those of the majority shareholder. They will function a lot like Air New Zealand which is subject to a less vigorous monitoring regime by the Treasury than fully state-owned companies.

This is complex territory and not the sort of stuff which makes for easily digested sound-bites. But Cosgrove and Labour must think laterally if they want to keep the party's anti-privatisation campaign alive. They may have triumphed in battle this week, but they remain at serious risk of losing the war.

- NZ Herald

John Armstrong

John Armstrong is the Herald's chief political commentator

Herald political correspondent John Armstrong has been covering politics at a national level for nearly 30 years. Based in the Press Gallery at Parliament in Wellington, John has worked for the Herald since 1987. John was named Best Columnist at the 2013 Canon Media Awards and was a previous winner of Qantas media awards as best political columnist. Prior to joining the Herald, John worked at Parliament for the New Zealand Press Association. A graduate of Canterbury University's journalism school, John began his career in journalism in 1981 on the Christchurch Star. John has a Masters of Arts degree in political science from Canterbury.

Read more by John Armstrong

Have your say

We aim to have healthy debate. But we won't publish comments that abuse others. View commenting guidelines.

1200 characters left

Sort by
  • Oldest

© Copyright 2014, APN New Zealand Limited

Assembled by: (static) on red akl_a5 at 23 Sep 2014 16:30:31 Processing Time: 950ms