Man caught in police child-sex sting appeals sentence

By Melissa Nightingale

Ian James Walsh is appealing his sentence. Photo / File
Ian James Walsh is appealing his sentence. Photo / File

A man sent to prison after being caught in a police sting sending explicit online messages to who he thought was a 13-year-old girl is appealing his sentence.

Ian James Walsh is today appealing to the High Court at Wellington against the prison sentence of two years and three months he was given in September on charges of making an objectionable publication, sending indecent communication, and travelling to meet a young person following sexual grooming.

Walsh was in contact earlier this year with a police officer posing as the child online. He sent hundreds of messages about wanting to massage the girl, photograph her and give her alcohol, Radio New Zealand reported.

Walsh also said he wanted to have sex with the girl.

He was arrested when he went to meet the "girl" at McDonald's, RNZ said.

The charge of making an objectionable publication related to Walsh filming a four-minute video of a naked prepubescent girl, they said.

During the appeal, for which Walsh was not present, defence lawyer Chris Tennet, said there should be a "distinguishment" for the fact the situation was "fake" and "there's no harm, immediate harm to a young person".

He acknowledged Walsh "dilly dallied and bit into it and did it".

"He accepted that and pleaded guilty."

Justice Dobson did not like Tennet's statement the offence was an "attempt".

"It's not an attempt. Mr Walsh should know that he completed all the elements of the offence," Justice Dobson said.

Tennet said there should be a "lesser starting point" in sentencing for offenders who were dealing with a "fictitious" person.

"He should be given credit for his good fortune that he wasn't dealing with who he thought he was dealing with," Justice Dobson said.

Tennet said the large part of the sentence - two years' imprisonment - was imposed for making the objectionable publication.

He called the sentence "manifestly excessive".

Justice Dobson noted the sentencing judge had not given Walsh an uplift in his sentence for previous convictions.

"It's not a good history, is it?" he said.

He noted that Walsh had a 1999 conviction for abduction a female for sex.

Crown prosecutor Seamus Woods said if harm had come to a young person during the sting, that would be an aggravating feature, but the absence of an aggravating feature did not make it a mitigating feature.

Woods said Walsh "demonstrated a lack of insight and did not appear to understand the seriousness of the offending".

Justice Dobson said he would reserve his decision.

- NZ Herald

Get the news delivered straight to your inbox

Receive the day’s news, sport and entertainment in our daily email newsletter

SIGN UP NOW

© Copyright 2017, NZME. Publishing Limited

Assembled by: (static) on production apcf03 at 29 Mar 2017 15:13:15 Processing Time: 636ms