Lincoln Tan is the New Zealand Herald’s diversity, ethnic affairs and immigration senior reporter.

Super City elections 2013: Single ward with two identities

As local body voting papers go out, the Herald examines the Super City's wards, analysing the big issues.

Avondale town centre is part of the Whau ward for this year's local body elections. Photo / Dean Purcell
Avondale town centre is part of the Whau ward for this year's local body elections. Photo / Dean Purcell

Four years since the creation of Whau - carved from areas previously managed by two different councils - residents still struggle to identify themselves as one ward.

Many in the New Lynn area said they have little in common with people in neighbouring Avondale, and did not wish to be linked to the "poorer'' suburb.

"New Lynn is progressing, especially our town centre where we have new residential properties being developed and even a new weekly night market,'' said New Lynn resident Bobbyn Zhang.

"Avondale, well there is no progress there, so if we say that we belong to the same area when it could pull down the property prices in New Lynn.''

Six out of 10 people who spoke to the Herald outside the Lynnmall shopping centre last week knew there was a local body election, but most did not know they were part of the Whau ward.

It's a different story in Avondale though, where most knew where they belonged and about the local elections - but nearly all couldn't name any of the candidates besides Noelene Raffills.

However, the slow progress at Avondale - in contrast to the fast and visible progress at the former Waitakere City Council-managed New Lynn - is souring support for Mrs Raffills.

Housewife Kim Tuivaiti, who shops at Avondale Sunday market, said she still harboured bitterness about Mrs Raffills playing a part in axing plans for a $10 million swimming pool in 2007.

"And look at what has happened in the last four years, absolutely nothing, and what's worse is that we are also going to lose our Sunday market,'' said Mrs Tuivaiti.

Mrs Raffills is being challenged in the single ward seat by Ross Clow, who is standing on a Labour ticket and Community First's Duncan MacDonald, another known name in the local community.

Mr MacDonald was the chairman of the former Avondale Community Board and is the deputy chairman on the new Whau board and works as a retailer in the area.

He is promising to push the new Avondale Action Plan through, which would include establishing a new library, community and recreation centres and swimming pool in the area.

"We [also] need to concentrate on better public transport, especially park and ride facilities.''

Mr Clow, a former Waitakere New Lynn ward councillor, claims credit for the developments in New Lynn which he said "did not happen during the watch of any of my opponents''.

"We turned New Lynn from a tired dilapidated centre into a poster boy project for sensible and sustainable urban development,'' Mr Clow said.

"I support the Unitary Plan, and will push for similar developments, such as apartments in Avondale, to ensure affordable housing is available for both young and old in the ward.''

The Auckland Council website says transport has always been a big issue in Whau.

The suburbs of New Lynn, Green Bay and Kelston, Rosebank, Avondale, New Windsor and Blockhouse Bay comprise the Whau Local Board area, and the name Whau is from the estuarine arm of the Waitemata Harbour that extends into the area.

Mrs Raffills acknowledged "bringing the community together'' was one of the big challenges, given the diversity, in ethnic make-up and income, of those living in the area.

She has made a u-turn on a previous decision and is now supporting having a swimming pool in the ward and believes Avondale is in urgent need of a facilities upgrade.

"In 2007, I had to take a city councillor's view ... and that was my considered opinion then. Now that we've become a Super City, it's important that we don't just carry over everything that I previously thought as a city councillor,'' she said.

Mrs Raffills said she was backing the council's strategic development plan for Avondale, which would see a community hub, apartments, retail and commercial buildings being developed on parts of the racecourse, Racecourse Parade and the Highbury Triangle - which also has the support of the Whau board and the Avondale Business Association, which Mr MacDonald chairs.

"I am excited about the future for Avondale,'' she said.

Other candidates are also promising a focus on Avondale, with Community Independents local board candidate Paul Davie accusing the current board of being fixated on the New Lynn plan "and the rest of the ward has suffered''.

"I can see no stand-out improvements from the amalgamation, and the focus needs to be redirected from primarily on buildings and more so on to the residents and what they actually want and need,'' Mr Davie said.

Hagen Robertson, who is standing on the Mana ticket, said the biggest issue for Whau was the lack of consultation between the council and community and would facilitate greater participation at community level if she was elected.

Labour's Chinese candidate Susan Zhu said she had been told by police that 9000 households in the ward were Chinese, and she wanted to be the voice for the ward's diverse communities. Ms Zhu believed the key tasks for the next council would be efficient transport options, affordable housing and more local jobs.

Ward profile - Whau

Ethnicity: European 44.3 per cent, Asian 31.5 per cent, Pacific 17.9 per cent, Maori 9 per cent
Birthplace: New Zealand 54.9 per cent, overseas 45.1 per cent
Median household income: $52,315
Current councillor: Noelene Raffills
Local board: Whau

Ward candidates (1 seat)

* Ross Clow, Labour
* Duncan Macdonald, Community First
* Noelene Raffills, Independent

Local board candidates (7 seats)

* John Anderson, Community Independents
* Heidi Bale, Affordable Auckland
* Derek Battersby, Progressive Independents
* Ami Chand, Labour
* Jia Jia Chen, Progressive Independents
* Ross Clow, Labour
* Kathryn Davie, Community Independents
* Paul Davie, Community Independents
* Catherine Farmer, Labour
* Gordon Gibbons, Community First
* Francis Lai, Community First
* Judy Lawley, Totally Independent
* Duncan Macdonald, Community First
* Glenys Macdonald, Community First
* Winnie Maeata'anoa, Community Independents
* Ruby Manukia-Schaumkel, Labour
* Simon Matafai, Labour
* Raj Mitra, Community First
* Thomas O'Rourke, Conservative
* Anna Parsons, Independent
* Manilal Patel, Community Independents
* Hagen Robertson, Mana Movement
* Reuben Shadbolt, Independent
* Sandy Taylor, Progressive Independents
* Allan John Thompson, Independent
* Bernadette Thomsen, Community First
* Mark Tulloch, Community Independents
* Lawrence Watt, Independent
* Jack Weir, Progressive Independents
* Glen Wilkin-Holland, Community Independents
* Howie Yin, Community First
* Susan Zhu, Labour.

Local body basics

There are three main contests:

1. Mayoral election
2. 20 councillors from 13 wards
3. 21 local boards

Key dates

September 20-25: Postal voting papers delivered
October 12: Election day

This week

Monday: Orakei
Yesterday: Howick
Today: Whau.

For more on the candidates in your local area see

- NZ Herald

Get the news delivered straight to your inbox

Receive the day’s news, sport and entertainment in our daily email newsletter


© Copyright 2017, NZME. Publishing Limited

Assembled by: (static) on production apcf05 at 23 May 2017 06:16:38 Processing Time: 1143ms