Matthew Backhouse is a NZME. News Service journalist based in Auckland.

Journalist 'furious' at fabrication claims

War correspondent Jon Stephenson giving evidence in his defamation case against Defence Force chief Lieutenant General Rhys Jones in the High Court at Wellington. Photo / Mark Mitchell
War correspondent Jon Stephenson giving evidence in his defamation case against Defence Force chief Lieutenant General Rhys Jones in the High Court at Wellington. Photo / Mark Mitchell

A Kiwi war correspondent who is suing the Defence Force for defamation says he was furious when he was accused of fabricating a visit to an Afghan base.

Jon Stephenson claims he was defamed by Defence Force chief Lieutenant General Rhys Jones after writing two articles about SAS soldiers transferring Afghan detainees to authorities who tortured them.

The articles mentioned a meeting between Stephenson and the commander of an Afghan crisis response unit (CRU) base in April 2010.

The Defence Force later released a press statement which said the commander denied speaking with Stephenson and that the reporter had been denied entry to the base.

Stephenson, a freelance journalist who has reported extensively from Afghanistan, has tried to get the Defence Force to retract the statement but it still appears on the NZDF website.

Giving evidence before a jury in the High Court at Wellington today, Stephenson spoke of his shock when he first saw the statement.

"I was furious, and frankly I still am."

He said journalists were not in the business of being popular and he expected criticism - but General Jones had not not attacked him on the issue, but on "something completely irrelevant".

"He played the man, not the ball."

Stephenson said the NZDF sent the statement to one of the most extensive news media distribution lists he had ever seen, including both major television channels and all the major newspapers and radio stations.

His lawyer Davey Salmon asked him if any news outlets had been left out, to which Stephenson replied: "None that comes to mind. Even I'm on the list."

Stephenson said he knew many of the reporters on the list, some of whom were senior journalists and others who were "very close friends".

He said he immediately started getting calls about the statement, and the blood rushed to his face with the shock.

"The phone just started ringing, person after person wanting a statement, wanting a comment," he said.

"I just had a sense of intense confusion and anger. I was just perplexed, I couldn't understand."

Many media outlets wrote stories using the statement or published it in full, he said.

Asked how the accusation had affected him, Stephenson said being fair, accurate and professional was at the heart of journalism.

"But to make stuff up, you don't do that, and all my colleagues sitting here will tell you that a journalist who fabricates information gets shown the door - no ifs, no buts. You don't do it."

The jury was this morning played an audio recording of a voice memo Stephenson dictated following his visit to the CRU base.

Stephenson told the jury he made "extensive" notes about the meeting when he returned to Kabul with his translator and driver, in addition to his initial notes during the meeting.

He then made a voice memo based on the notes and other observations from the base about 3am.

Stephenson said he then destroyed the second set of notes and stored the voice memo on his laptop using encryption.

In the recording, Stephenson said he initially went to the CRU base on April 25 but was denied entry.

He could see both the Afghan and New Zealand flags flying within the base.

The next day he returned and was "more successful". He was allowed entry to the CRU base, where he met with the commander.

He described the room where they met, which was lit with fluorescent lights and had a low ceiling.

Stephenson said he and the commander had discussed the role and reputation of the New Zealand troops, including the transfer of detainees to Afghan authorities.

General Jones sat within the courtroom, while investigative reporter Nicky Hager sat in support of Stephenson in the court's public gallery.

The trial continues.


Get the news delivered straight to your inbox

Receive the day’s news, sport and entertainment in our daily email newsletter


© Copyright 2017, NZME. Publishing Limited

Assembled by: (static) on production bpcf02 at 27 Apr 2017 03:21:30 Processing Time: 367ms