Kirsty Wynn

Kirsty Wynn is a senior reporter at the Herald on Sunday.

Taxpayer funded forecasters in fight for territory

Metservice and Niwa are in a fight over short term forecasts.
Metservice and Niwa are in a fight over short term forecasts.

Weather forecasts are being publicly funded on two fronts with both Niwa and Metservice now offering short range forecasts, using taxpayer funds to compete against each other.

The launch of Niwa's new short range service for farmers and growers puts it in a head-to-head battle with Metservice, while private forecasters fear the government forecasters' combined clout could heavy them out of the market.

Niwa is publicly funded as a Crown Research Institute and Metservice receives Ministry of Transport funding to provide free forecasting and severe weather warning services.

Metservice's Jacqui Bridges said there were differences between the services but customers were asking why publicly funded services were competing.

"We have had comments from people that they find it strange," Bridges said.

"Metservice is a commercial service so we compete. If people want to compete with us they can compete with us and we are up for that."

Niwa chief scientist for atmosphere, Dr Murray Poulter, would not comment on the relationship between Metservice and Niwa.

Comments on blog site The New Zealand Weather Forum called for Niwa to apply for the Ministry of Transport funding. "If Niwa is smart they should apply for the ministry of transport contract later, once they have all the services laid out," said poster Tornado Tim.

"There would be no point in releasing these products to the public if they thought Metservice's products were enough."

Others called for the Government to set boundaries so taxpayers weren't paying twice.

Private forecaster WeatherWatch supported Niwa branching out from long range weather and climate research.

The organisation has a troubled relationship with Metservice which was made worse last year with a price increase of $30,000 for daily highs - forcing WeatherWatch to scrap the service.

"We have always had a good working relationship with NIWA and I am cautiously optimistic that a closer WeatherWatch and NIWA relationship is going to be a very positive change for the weather industry and the New Zealand public," said Philip Duncan from WeatherWatch.

"They are larger than MetService so I'd expect them to have the resources to really do the job well provided they work proactively with private industry.

"I don't think there should be two separate government forecasters competing in the same market, at the expense of private providers and, ultimately, the public."

- Herald on Sunday

© Copyright 2014, APN New Zealand Limited

Assembled by: (static) on production bpcf05 at 24 Oct 2014 00:52:03 Processing Time: 414ms