Guy case stays open after search

By Andrew Koubaridis

Investigators into killing say unsuccessful pond hunt is 'only one piece of the puzzle'.

Dredging of effluent ponds has revealed no clues in the hunt for the murderer of farmer Scott Guy.
Dredging of effluent ponds has revealed no clues in the hunt for the murderer of farmer Scott Guy.

Private investigators looking for clues to who killed Scott Guy will not be put off by news the effluent ponds on the Guy farm were not hiding evidence left by the murderer.

There had been suspicions that evidence - such as the dive boots police believe the killer was wearing - was discarded in the ponds. But a nine-day search this month found only rubbish and cattle ear tags.

The Herald has been told the investigators, hired by Scott Guy's wife, Kylee Guy, do not view the development as a setback and will continue with their work in the hope of finding a breakthrough.

A source said dredging the ponds was an important step but was only "one piece of the puzzle".

Police said the dredging operation was "difficult and challenging".

The officer in charge, Superintendent Sue Schwalger, said the decision to dredge the ponds was made after consulting Guy family members.

"Police made the decision to dredge the ponds after it was flagged by the family and other interested parties as a potential issue. Police wanted to provide reassurance to the family and others that there was nothing of interest in the ponds."

The case remains open and police have said they will examine any new lead they receive.

"The key to any investigation is to have an open mind. As with the original investigation, police spent many hours investigating and eliminating the numerous rumours and speculation, so after further consideration of a range of views and discussions with Kylee and the Guy family police decided to take this step."

Mr Guy was shot dead in the driveway of his Feilding farm on July 8, 2010. After a nine-month investigation his brother-in-law and business partner Ewen Macdonald was charged with murder.

A jury found him not guilty of murder nearly a year ago, but he is serving a jail sentence for crimes he admitted committing against Scott and Kylee Guy and others.

In a statement, the dead man's parents, Bryan and Jo Guy, said: "The question of draining the ponds has been raised on a few occasions.

"The police had asked if they could take the opportunity to dredge the silt once the water had been drained.

"We were happy to co-operate with the request to provide an answer, and put that particular question to rest."


What have police done?
They have sifted through sludge up to 2m deep that was left at the bottom of effluent ponds on the Guy family farm.

Why have they done it?
There had been speculation that evidence could be in the sludge relating to the murder of Scott Guy. The family told police it was an issue for them and police say they wanted to reassure them.

How did they do it?
The two ponds were drained of their liquid and then silt and sludge was removed, sifted and raked through. Nothing of significance was found. The operation this month took nine days and a total of between 400 and 500 tonnes of silt and farm waste was removed.

- NZ Herald

Get the news delivered straight to your inbox

Receive the day’s news, sport and entertainment in our daily email newsletter


© Copyright 2016, NZME. Publishing Limited

Assembled by: (static) on production apcf04 at 25 Aug 2016 05:38:46 Processing Time: 672ms