However, when he sent out a media release a fortnight ago saying the FNDC would allow time to find a new site for the shelter, Mayor Wayne Brown objected to the delay in actioning the board ruling.
Mrs Chapman said she and her volunteers were devastated by the shelter's removal, particularly as the community board had in previous years praised their work in neutering stray cats.
She thinks Bay Bush Action, a volunteer group eliminating pests in the Opua State Forest, to have had a key role in the shelter's expulsion from the reserve.
"Bay Bush has been on the scene only 18 months yet they are throwing their weight around in an urban area when they should be catching ferals (wild cats) in the Opua forest," Mrs Chapman said.
The 10 Paihia cats were neutered and caused no harm. They were used to being fed at the shelter and she and her volunteers wanted to see them live out their days peacefully.
"If we (the cat feeding team) are wiped more dumped cats will turn up in Paihia,"she said.