John Armstrong on politics
John Armstrong is the Herald's chief political commentator

John Armstrong: Lobby group's anti-MMP blitz piggybacks on Key's popularity

John Key. Photo / NZPA
John Key. Photo / NZPA

Referendum? What referendum? In contrast to the highly turbulent waters of the election campaign, Saturday's simultaneous vote on the electoral system has been a backwater of relative calm.

That was until yesterday - and the appearance of a half-page newspaper advertisement carrying a large photograph of John Key and quoting him as voting to "get rid of MMP", accompanied by the question: "Will you?"

This last-minute advertising blitz by the anti-MMP group, Vote for Change, will not surprise the pro-MMP counterpart Campaign for MMP, but it will cause some nervousness, especially if yesterday's ad is the precursor of a series of increasingly tough attack ads on MMP.

The Campaign for MMP will be responding with some print and radio ads featuring former All Black Anton Oliver. But these are unlikely to be as blunt or direct as those of its opponent.

So far, the pro-MMP lobby has managed to hold the line. Most polls show a preference for retaining MMP.

However, things are starting to get messy with the election campaign starting to barge into the referendum debate.

Not only is Vote for Change piggybacking on Key's popularity, Key is bagging Winston Peters. In doing so, he is raising Peters' profile and - as Peters is the worst advertisement for MMP - bagging MMP in the process.

All this is giving Vote for Change a last-minute fillip. The anti-MMP lobby has struggled for traction. Efforts to push the cause of the supplementary member system as a suitable halfway house between MMP and first-past-the-post have been a flop.

While Key - with other National MPs - has occasionally murmured a preference for supplementary member, the politicians have been reluctant to engage on the referendum.

Supplementary member now appears doomed. It is most unlikely to secure anywhere near enough backing to emerge as the favoured alternative to MMP. That most likely means any run-off at the 2014 election would pit MMP against first-past-the-post, the system MMP replaced.

The pro-MMP lobby is trying to take advantage of this, reminding voters they will get an independent review of MMP if they vote to retain the status quo, with a look at prime voter gripes, such as the deal-making in Epsom.


Every which way: Pita Sharples insists the Maori Party opposes asset sales - but will support iwi getting first pick when shares in state-owned companies come onto the market.
They said it: "That's a good question. And I don't have a good answer." - Act leader Don Brash, asked by Kathryn Ryan on National Radio why he floated the decriminalisation of marijuana.
"I'll even shout him a cup of coffee. But it will have to be in a takeaway cup." - Winston Peters invites John Key to debate the issues at Peters' open-air public meeting in Auckland's Aotea Square tomorrow.

- NZ Herald

Get the news delivered straight to your inbox

Receive the day’s news, sport and entertainment in our daily email newsletter


Have your say

1200 characters left

By and large our readers' comments are respectful and courteous. We're sure you'll fit in well.
View commenting guidelines.

Sort by
  • Oldest

© Copyright 2017, NZME. Publishing Limited

Assembled by: (static) on production bpcf04 at 29 May 2017 20:15:45 Processing Time: 525ms