Council's leaky homes claims soar to $240m

By Anne Gibson

Leaky homes claims in Auckland City total $240 million. File photo / Herald on Sunday
Leaky homes claims in Auckland City total $240 million. File photo / Herald on Sunday

Auckland City is dealing with $240 million of leaky homes claims, the highest in New Zealand for any one council.

Yesterday it issued a list of active claims showing 42 multi-unit cases claiming $201,433,000 and 94 single houses claiming $39,345,155.

That compares with the city council's total debt of $322 million.

Claimants are bringing cases in the High Court and via the Government's weathertightness service and tribunal against the city for its role in the leaky building scandal.

Already, the council has paid out $50.9 million for 300 leaky building cases which cost $11.6 million in legal and expert fees.

The council said this was the amount of settled claims for both single and multi-unit dwellings.

This year's bill was slightly less frightening and the council claimed a share of victory.

"The total amount paid by the council was $11.4 million for 54 claims with a further $3.2 million for professional fees, making total payments $14.6 million," said a report to the council's finance and strategy committee.

"This figure is down sharply from last year when total council payments were $23 million ($19.6 million for 57 claims and another $3.4 million for professional fees).

"A more efficient approach with the use of specialised officers together with a lesser number of high value multi-units claims being ready to litigate are the likely causes for the improvement in 2009's financial results," the council said.

It referred to diminishing liability on the rented apartments/house front.

"In the last few months several decisions have been released by the High Court and the Court of Appeal reinforcing the lack of duty owed by council to a building owner where that building has a commercial use," the council said, referring to rental properties.

Last week, the Court of Appeal finished hearing claims on two major North Shore multi-unit blocks - Byron Ave and Sunset Terraces.

Auckland City noted that the arguments here partly centred on whether councils were responsible for houses which were rented.

The council said it wanted the Government to play more of a role in the national scandal but warned there was no quick fix.

* Sky high Auckland

Number of individual properties with active claims as at August 31:

Auckland 1920

North Shore 453

Manukau 123

Rodney 93

Waitakere 351

Papakura 0

Hamilton 32

Christchurch 322

Dunedin 2

National total: 3891

Source: Department of Building and Housing

Settled claims for Auckland City Council

No. of Claims 300

Council Contribution $50,941,395

Legal & Expert Fees $11,602,586

(both single dwellings and multi unit complexes)

Active claims:


No. of Claims 42

Amount claimed by homeowners $201,433,000


No. of Claims 94

Amount claimed by homeowners $39,345,155

Source: Auckland City report

- NZ Herald

Get the news delivered straight to your inbox

Receive the day’s news, sport and entertainment in our daily email newsletter


© Copyright 2017, NZME. Publishing Limited

Assembled by: (static) on production apcf04 at 25 May 2017 12:44:25 Processing Time: 11ms