But Mr Petherick said the police dog still thought something was amiss and an officer decided to check out the roof cavity of the home.
"It wasn't long before he located two large bags in the roof cavity containing cigarettes and tobacco worth an estimated $5000 we believe were taken during the burglary.
"But then, as his eyes adjusted to the light, the officer saw something else that perked his interest - what appeared to be a toe poking out of insulation."
The owner of the toe accepted the officer's invitation to come out - before the police dog was tasked with investigating the new find.
A 20-year-old man was arrested and both men were to appear in the Hamilton District Court, charged with burglary.