Movie review: Silence of Love

Add a comment
Photo / Supplied
Photo / Supplied

The new film by the writer-director of 2008's brilliant I've Loved You So Long, in which Kristin Scott Thomas played a woman just released from prison, is an altogether lighter affair. Wistful and bittersweet, it lacks the dramatic punch of its predecessor - indeed, the pacing is a bit loose at times - but it is distinguished by the same emotional intelligence and lucidity and makes a rewarding watch.

Accorsi, a familiar face to Italian Film Festival audiences, plays Alessandro, an Italian-born professor of Baroque music in the French city of Strasbourg, who still mourns his late wife, Louise, 15 years after her death. He copes by infantilising the now-teenage daughter she left him with, Irina (Cipriani), who is in some ways more mature than he is: she remarks that Louise "takes up so much space" in their small flat. There is still room for Alessandro's anarchist painter brother Luigi (Marcore) who, in a running gag, is in self-imposed exile and refuses to leave the house, as a protest against the incumbency of Silvio Berlusconi.

Alessandro's loneliness - and the attempts of others to rescue him from it - is the spine of a story that is sharply observed, crisply written and packed with detail.

The various subplots make for a large cast - Alessandro's circle of friends; workmates; the hospice patients he visits as a volunteer (including Agathe, a luminous Aimee, 80 in April) - yet it never feels cluttered and each of the characters is well-drawn.

And the elegance with which Claudel contrives to have a catastrophically ill-advised piece of matchmaking turn out both dreadfully and wonderfully is something to behold.

It's a script assembled with a cabinetmaker's precision and forethought: even the setting's ravishingly handsome city - in part of France that has repeatedly been part of Germany - underlines the theme of rootlessness and identity that is so central to the main characters' emotional arcs. And the main characters - especially father and daughter - are effortlessly charming.

For a romantic comedy, this film has a serious heart: the significance of its English title takes on different hues as the story progresses. It is, in the end, a film about how hard we make it for ourselves to be loved. As Agathe says cryptically: "The dead have their whole lives ahead of them; it's the absent who haunt us most." Recommended.

Stars: 3.5/5
Cast: Stefano Accorsi, Neri Marcore, Clotilde Courau, Lisa Cipriani, Anouk Aimee
Director: Philippe Claudel
Running time: 102 mins
Rating: M (offensive language) In French and Italian with English subtitles
Verdict: Bittersweet and rewarding


- NZ Herald

Get the news delivered straight to your inbox

Receive the day’s news, sport and entertainment in our daily email newsletter


Have your say

1200 characters left

By and large our readers' comments are respectful and courteous. We're sure you'll fit in well.
View commenting guidelines.

© Copyright 2015, NZME. Publishing Limited

Assembled by: (static) on production apcf04 at 09 Oct 2015 07:05:14 Processing Time: 574ms