The "yes" argument points out that silver's price is at near three-year lows. However if the US economy keeps improving, the printing of money slows and the US dollar strengthens, then the safety of silver and gold is less attractive.
In its favour is that silver is underperforming gold despite the latter's own heavy falls: an ounce of gold at US$1212 would buy 66 ounces of silver now, compared to 33 ounces when it was at its 2011 record high.
MineLife senior resources analyst Gavin Wendt said he thought silver was cheap.
"I think it's a good buy, I would be buying gold and silver around current levels for sure," he said.
Wendt pointed out that silver can still perform well if the US economy improves since it has strong industrial applications and is not as much of a defensive, value-hedging asset as gold.
That doesn't translate to good news for silver miners in Australia however, where BHP Billiton's Cannington project in Queensland is the world's largest silver mine.
On the ASX, exchange-traded fund silver was trading at A$20.03 on Monday, representing a 33 per cent fall for the year.
- AAP