Hart launches fresh bid to save career

By Edward Gay

High profile lawyer Barry Hart has been found guilty of professional misconduct. Photo / File
High profile lawyer Barry Hart has been found guilty of professional misconduct. Photo / File

Disgraced lawyer Barry Hart has launched a fresh bid to continue his 46-year career - as it emerged his fleet of luxury cars had been seized by debt collectors.

The 71-year-old criminal defence lawyer was struck off after the Lawyers and Conveyancers Disciplinary Tribunal found him guilty of three charges of misconduct earlier this month.

Today he went to the High Court at Auckland seeking permission to represent existing clients until an appeal against that decision is heard in December.

His lawyer Jeremy Bioletti said Hart's career at the "sharp end'' of criminal law would be over if he could not represent his clients, who would be adversely affected.

Law Society's Standards Committee lawyer Jan McCartney SC said Hart had already had plenty of time to tell clients he was facing disciplinary proceedings and ran the risk of being struck off.

She said the High Court could allow Hart to continue acting as a lawyer only if it found the tribunal had been "wholly wrong'' and that was not the case.

In response to the claim that Hart's business would be ended, Ms McCartney said the High Court had acted quickly to give Hart an appeal date in December.

She said many of Hart's upcoming court appearances were for minor matters and could be carried out by other lawyer.

"There is an issue of protection of the public. The practitioner has been found to be not a fit and proper person.''

She said there was a concern that other people could be put at risk if Hart was allowed to continue his practice.

"The tribunal held that Mr Hart exploited the vulnerable; and those are the very people Mr Hart seeks to continue to represent.''

In reply Mr Bioletti said the case had developed an "element of hysteria''.

"With the amount of publicity, surely anyone who is represented by Mr Hart could walk out of the situation.''

Justice Graham Lang reserved his decision.

Outside court, Hart declined to comment.

He was found guilty of unsatisfactory conduct for overcharging on two occasions in 2010 and again a year later.

In its disciplinary decision, the tribunal said Hart's case was aggravated by his "poor disciplinary history'', which included seven previous findings against him.

One for "gross overcharging'' was 30 years old, but identical in nature to the latest case.

The pattern of behaviour meant the tribunal had "no confidence in either his rehabilitation or protection of the public by ensuring there is no risk of reoffending''.

"We accept that striking off, particularly in a practitioner of such seniority, is a last resort response,'' said chairwoman Judge Dale Clarkson.

Hart has also lost his multimillion dollar properties north-west of Auckland after owing $30 million to the ANZ National Bank.

It has also been revealed that his fleet of luxury cars - including an Aston Martin and a 2011 Ferrari California - have been seized by debt collectors.

They will be up for sale at a Turners auction this weekend.

Turners chief executive Graham Roberts said the Ferrari was like "one out of the box'' and only had 350km on the clock.

"This is not your `in your face Ferrari, red, look who I am'. It's an understated elegant car.''

- APNZ

© Copyright 2014, APN New Zealand Limited

Assembled by: (static) on production apcf01 at 31 Oct 2014 01:33:28 Processing Time: 1005ms