Dana Johannsen 's Opinion

Dana Johannsen is the NZ Herald’s chief sports reporter

Dana Johannsen: Stars need to lead injury message

11 comments
George Smith of the Wallabies returned to the field after a severe head clash.  Photo / Getty Images
George Smith of the Wallabies returned to the field after a severe head clash. Photo / Getty Images

The brain is an incredibly important organ. You probably don't need reminding of this.

The brain has a similar consistency to soft tofu. It seems some of us might need reminding of this.

I say this because for all the sobering research and devastating first-hand accounts that have emerged in recent years about the dangers of concussion, it is apparent after the first part of the international rugby season that attitudes to head injuries are still infuriatingly lax.

Take some of the Twitter worship from well-known rugby stars when Wallabies loose forward George Smith returned to the field in the third test against the Lions just five minutes after leaving after a sickening head clash with Lions hooker Richard Hibbard. In his own words Smith "snake-danced off the field" after the collision, and in the eyes of many observers he was clearly concussed.

The decision to send Smith back on after the incident was foolhardy, yet on social media Smith was widely lauded as a hero for his "brave" return - not just from Wallabies fans, but some of world rugby's big names.

Ma'a Nonu reckoned Smith was "1 tough Mother", while Matt Giteau described him as "unbelievably tough" and former English international Will Carling has this to say: "George Smith back on! Fair play must have had some bloody strong smelling salts."

Fair play? No Will, bloody stupid play. Alarmingly, between the trio they have over 265,000 Twitter followers - Nonu's nonsense was retweeted 71 times.

There were similarly worrying attitudes coming from the All Black camp before their test series against France last month. Heading into the series, halfback Piri Weepu's role was in doubt after he was knocked out against the Highlanders in the final round before the Super rugby hiatus. He was stretchered off the field, but two days later a bubbly and bright Weepu was fronting media and reassuring everyone that he would be right to play in the opening test the coming weekend.

While All Black management and medical staff were saying all the right things about the need to take a conservative approach and manage Weepu's injury carefully, their messages were undone by the halfback's insistence that he was fine to play.

For all the work administrators are trying to do to educate the rugby community about the dangers of head injuries, it is clear a massive cultural shift is needed to tackle the issue and it is the game's stars who need to lead that charge. Rugby culture demands a tolerance to pain: getting up and playing on after taking a massive hit is seen as the mark of a courageous player.

When kids see their heroes playing on when they are obviously affected by a head knock, they think it is a heroic act; what they need to think is that they're being stupid. And that's only going to happen if stars like Nonu stop lauding head-injured players as being "1 tough Mother" and instead say "not cool, bro".

- NZ Herald

Dana Johannsen

Dana Johannsen is the NZ Herald’s chief sports reporter

Dana has more than a decade’s experience in sports journalism, joining the Herald in 2007 following stints with TVNZ and RadioSport. Over that time Dana has covered several major events including the 2011 Netball World Cup in Singapore, 2011 Rugby World Cup, 2012-13 Volvo Ocean Race, and the 34th America’s Cup in San Francisco. A multi-award winning journalist, Dana was named New Zealand Sports Journalist of the Year in 2012 after scooping both the news and feature categories at the TP McLean Awards. The previous year she picked up the prize for best news break. She was also an inaugural recipient of the Sir John Wells scholarship at the 2009 NZSJA awards. Dana also writes a weekly sports column for the NZ Herald.

Read more by Dana Johannsen

Have your say

We aim to have healthy debate. But we won't publish comments that abuse others. View commenting guidelines.

1200 characters left

Sort by
  • Oldest
Stats provided by

© Copyright 2014, APN New Zealand Limited

Assembled by: (static) on production apcf01 at 23 Dec 2014 07:53:47 Processing Time: 328ms