Audrey Young 's Opinion

Audrey Young is the New Zealand Herald’s political editor.

Audrey Young: A fish out of water whose leadership never took off

52 comments
David Shearer announcing his resignation.  Photo / Mark Mitchell
David Shearer announcing his resignation. Photo / Mark Mitchell

The manner in which David Shearer has exited his leadership of the Labour Party is a prime example of why it came to an end.

He couldn't do it properly.

Shearer made a statement, refused to take questions, and is said by staff to be heading off for two or three weeks' leave.

It looked like a man running away, who couldn't take the pressure.

Yesterday's announcement was a dramatic end to a difficult leadership, which would have ended in a no-confidence motion being moved next week had he not pre-empted it.

Some of the first conversations on Twitter last week after Key's electric performance on Campbell Live were how inadequate Shearer would look against him in election debates.

Even when Shearer performed creditably as he did at the Auckland Town Hall meeting on the GCSB bill, he is almost always out-performed by Greens co-leader Russel Norman.

Even the good times were bad. This week's stunt of bringing a couple of dead snapper into the House didn't impress many of the caucus but it wasn't the clincher.

It has been a leadership not so much in decline, as never taking off.

Shearer was a risk his supporters thought worth taking in 2011.

He was installed as leader by a combination of the right faction, and the part of the left faction that did not want David Cunliffe and who supported Grant Robertson as a future leader.

They knew that Robertson wasn't ready but in David Shearer they saw someone who could emulate the John Key success story - someone who was new to politics, who was seen more as a decent person, an outstanding humanitarian than a hardened politician.

Shearer was no match for Key who had been in politics for nine years and Prime Minister for three of them by that time.

Shortly after Shearer was elected leader in 2011, he asked John Key if he had any advice as the pair walked from the debating chamber to the Legislative Chamber for the opening of Parliament.

Key advised him to seize the moment and to make the most of his leadership in the early stages to push through the ideas he wanted early on.

Shearer didn't seize the moment, then or at any time.

One colleague said he didn't come to the top job with enough well-formed views, experience of how Parliament worked or the Labour Party worked.

He may have made an excellent Prime Minister but with his apprenticeship as an inexperienced politician in the most demanding of parties against a talented Prime Minister, the chances of getting there have been diminishing.

As one senior party member said yesterday: "He couldn't inspire, he couldn't communicate, he couldn't think on his feet. He's an honest person so he couldn't bullshit like Key."

Shearer's deficiencies were forgiven in the first year of his leadership but not the second.

He has had a distant and difficult relationship with the party which has lost the discipline it had under the Clark years.

The original open contest between Shearer and Cunliffe empowered the party and heightened the differences between the caucus and the party - the party tolerated his leadership at best.

The beginning of the end started in June when Labour slumped back to 30 per cent in the polls after having climbed to a respectable 35 per cent in the first half of the year.

The slump started rumours about spring coups.

The whispering was followed by the women-only selection proposal, dubbed the man-ban issue. For once Shearer was decisive and it played well with the public, but not with the party.

For him it was a no-win situation, the story of his leadership.

- NZ Herald

Audrey Young

Audrey Young is the New Zealand Herald’s political editor.

Audrey Young is the New Zealand Herald’s political editor, a job she has held since 2003. She is responsible for the Herald’s Press Gallery team. She first joined the New Zealand Herald in 1988 as a sub-editor after the closure of its tabloid rival, the Auckland Sun. She switched to reporting in 1991 as social welfare and housing reporter. She joined the Herald’s Press Gallery office in 1994. She has previously worked as a journalism tutor at Manukau Technical Institute, as member of the Newspapers in Education unit at Wellington Newspapers and as a teacher in Wellington. She was a union nominee on the Press Council for six years.

Read more by Audrey Young

Have your say

We aim to have healthy debate. But we won't publish comments that abuse others. View commenting guidelines.

1200 characters left

Sort by
  • Oldest

© Copyright 2014, APN New Zealand Limited

Assembled by: (static) on production bpcf01 at 26 Oct 2014 04:03:51 Processing Time: 546ms