His lawyers also argued there was "hyperbole" in the Crown's closing address.
However, the Supreme Court dismissed Pukeroa's second appeal in a decision released today rejecting all of his claims.
"We do not consider that the points raised on behalf of Mr Pukeroa created a risk of a miscarriage of justice," the court found.
"The court also did not consider that the question trail was overly complex. Any complexity arose because of the nature of the parties' cases."
Jordan Herewini was killed amid tensions between Murupara's Tribesmen and Kawerau's Mongrel Mob
On the day Jordan was killed, Pukeroa abused him for wearing a yellow shirt - the colour associated with the Tribesmen gang.
The abuse led to a fight in the town centre and escalated to Jordan being run over and killed on his property.