He had rushed outside to turn off the water mains but later discovered there was no piping under the shop floor.
A GeoNet seismologist in Wellington said he was not convinced the Northland incident was related to the big jolt felt hundreds of kilometres south.
However, there was no doubt in Allan's mind it was not a coincidence.
"Tremors were felt in Dargaville and that's not too far away from us," he said.
Mr Allan said he had pulled up the tiles to see if there were any cracks in the concrete that could provide some answers.
Maungatapere tiler Craig Horan, with nearly two decades in the tile business, said it was unusual for tiles to crack as they had. He said over time hairline fractures could develop and if grouting worked loose the tiles could crack.
He said it sounded as if there had been some pressure from below the tiles or the concrete block underneath had moved.