Moose pictures a load of bull

By Lindy Laird

1 comment


A Northland man credited with taking the best shots of wild moose in Fiordland took a secret to the grave - the photos Fred Stewardson claimed he snapped during a hunting trip in 1953 were a sham.

Mr Stewardson allegedly brought the photos out of the mists of time - and myth - last year. They showed three moose supposedly taken in the Wet Jacket Arm on the then 21-year old bushman's 35mm Agfa Super Sillette.

They were described by moose hunter, biologist and documentary filmmaker Ken Tustin as the best photos he had seen of live moose in remote Fiordland. Mr Tustin said that although some of Mr Stewardson's story was patchy, the photos had "knocked his socks off".

But subsequent research, including tracking down Mr Stewardson former wife in Australia, has revealed a hoax.

"It's taken me two years total, and nine months after his death, to establish that Fred Stewardson's moose photos, supposedly taken by him in Wet Jacket Arm in 1953, were actually taken by him in a national park in Banff, Canada, in 1958. Drat," Mr Tustin said yesterday.

When he "went public" last September, Mr Stewardson said he was intrigued by Mr Tustin's research into the possible survival of descendants of 10 moose released in the area in 1910.

The retired farmer, who lived near Hikurangi, claimed he had kept the photos secret to avoid unleashing a frenzy of wild moose chases. He said he now wanted the photos to see the light of day.

"If I croak, the story's gone forever," he told the Northern Advocate.

Instead, his "story" has become one more fallacy, another false trail in the great Fiordland moose hunt.

Last year Mr Tustin said he was disappointed the photos came too late to be included in his 2010 book A (Nearly) Complete History of Moose in New Zealand.

The photos nevertheless caused a stir and Mr Tustin felt obliged to put the record straight.

"It makes no difference to anything I'm doing or have done, other than I feel I should erase the record if I can, in case someone else is now sucked in," he said. "However, I must say I'm disappointed he carried his story, knowing it was not true, to such great lengths and distances.

"Moose history has always been cloaked in secrecy - this could be viewed as another slant on it."

- Northern Advocate

Sort by
  • Oldest

© Copyright 2014, APN New Zealand Limited

Assembled by: (static) on red akl_a1 at 21 Oct 2014 13:32:33 Processing Time: 979ms