Wreck removal agreement 'a sham', tribunal told

By Sandra Conchie

2 comments
Tom Bennion
Tom Bennion

A lawer for Motiti Island iwi has described the original wreck recovery agreement signed between the Crown and Rena's owner and insurers "as a sham".

Lawyer Janet Mason, representing two groups of claimants - Motiti Rohe Moana Trust and Mataahua District Maori Council - made the comment during a Waitangi Tribunal urgent inquiry into the Crown's conduct after Rena's grounding.

The inquiry began in Tauranga yesterday.

Last month, Rena's owners, Daina Shipping Company, and insurers, The Swedish Club, applied for a resource consent to leave the remains of the wreck on the reef.

An agreement between the Crown and the company was reached in 2012 under which $10.4 million would be paid to the Government if a resource consent was granted.

Ms Mason said disclosure documents made it clear there had been "backroom deals" and the wreck removal agreement was "a sham" and the Crown "knew it too".

Representatives from Motiti Island's Ngai te Hapu, the trust and the local Maori Council called on the tribunal to force the Government to enforce a 2011 Maritime New Zealand statutory notice which says the wreck must be removed.

Ngai te Hapu spokesperson Buddy Mikaere told the tribunal that the "bottom line" for him and the other Motiti Island hapu was for the complete removal of the wreck and all the debris.

"This is a sad day ... It almost makes me weep that under the Treaty of Waitangi and its principles the Government has acted less than honourably, putting a foreign company and its interests ahead of tangata whenua and our interests.

"The Crown says signing its secret deal was not a breach of the Treaty nor was the $10.4 million an incentive payment, we believe that is nonsense," he said.

"We say, we the owners, should have a say in all of this and we'd been denied that."

Mr Mikaere said the Crown deed agreement failed to recognise Astrolabe Reef as a taonga and as "customary owners" of the reef, the Government should have consulted Ngai te Hapu as required under the Treaty of Waitangi principles.

"But it's not just a Maori issue, it's a whole community issue because everybody has various reasons why they want this environmental disaster fixed," he said.

Ngai te Hapu's lawyer Tom Bennion described the $10.4 million as a "success fee" and an incentive for the Government to facilitate the shipping company's end goal of leaving the wreck on the reef. It would save the Rena's owner and insurers a substantial amount of money to do so, he said.

Mr Mikaere said he had been told the cost to remove the rest of the wreck and the debris would be between $500 million to $1 billion.

The inquiry continues today, with the Crown responding.

- Bay of Plenty Times

Have your say

We aim to have healthy debate. But we won't publish comments that abuse others. View commenting guidelines.

1200 characters left

Sort by
  • Oldest

© Copyright 2014, APN New Zealand Limited

Assembled by: (static) on red akl_a1 at 22 Oct 2014 01:34:46 Processing Time: 815ms