Session clerk Charles Mcdonald said the building needed extensive work which he estimated could cost millions and could not be paid for by the church.
Mr Mcdonald said the building had no foundations, no bracing, had borer in the wood and the roof was probably due to be replaced.
"We just don't have the money," he said.
Instead the church is asking someone to remove it from the Moresby Ave site, give it a new home and restore it.
The church had advertised the building through local newspapers and have now turned to Trade Me.
The listing said the church was willing to gift the building to anyone interested in giving it a new home. As at 4.30pm on Wednesday bidding for the building had reached $122.
St James Presbyterian Church
- Built in heart rimu with a corrugated iron roof
- Built in 1905 and opened in 1906
- Constructed in a cathedral cross configuration
- The building is 26.5m long and 15.5m wide