Kirsty Wynn

Kirsty Wynn is a senior reporter at the Herald on Sunday.

Tornado whips up new angst

MetService says strong gusts were predicted.

Wallingford Way in Hobsonville after the tornado struck. Photo / Michael Craig
Wallingford Way in Hobsonville after the tornado struck. Photo / Michael Craig

The Metservice has defended its failure to warn of a fatal tornado - even though a smaller competitor notified Civil Defence of the risk the night before.

Daniel Corbett from MetService said the Auckland weather event which killed three people this week was as much related to high wind gusts as tornadoes.

"It is a good word - small tornado - but it is not the only piece of the puzzle," Corbett said.

"That is is why we mentioned those wind gusts on the thunderstorm outlooks so people can know, 'my God, I might see 100km gusts today'."

New Zealand tornadoes were harder to predict than larger ones such as in the United States because they were too small to see on radar.

Corbett said warnings for the strong gusts were issued to Auckland Council and Civil Defence.

Tom Stowers, 42, of Massey; Keith Langford, 60, of Tuakau, and Brendon Johnson, 22, of Massey were killed at a construction site during the storm.

About 250 people were left homeless and thousands of homes were without power after the storm, which is estimated to have caused $11 million worth of damage. Vector said yesterday it hoped to have the final 30 homes without power reconnected overnight.

Prime Minister John Key told media on Friday the Government would look to improve its weather forecasting capabilities.

"As a general rule, you think you can pick these things up. I think there were predictions for heavy rain but not necessarily tornadoes so that's something we're going to have to go back and have a look at."

Phillip Duncan from WeatherWatch said he sent a low tornado risk warning through to Civil Defence the night before the fatal tornado.

"But I wouldn't have expected Civil Defence to have acted on that on their own without MetService saying anything.

"They do trust WeatherWatch but they wouldn't act on a warning from us alone."

Duncan said the tornado highlighted the need for more communication with state-owned MetService.

"I think it is time MetService and WeatherWatch work together like we did years ago with Bob McDavitt."

Duncan agreed tornadoes were hard to predict but said a warning about an increased risk or possibility was better than none at all.

- Herald on Sunday

© Copyright 2014, APN New Zealand Limited

Assembled by: (static) on red akl_a2 at 31 Jul 2014 18:15:32 Processing Time: 534ms