Isaac Davison

Isaac Davison is a NZ Herald political reporter.

More MPs opposing gay marriage

Labour MP Su'a William Sio gets a hug from Family First NZ member Steve McRobie after receiving the petition. Photo / Mark Mitchell
Labour MP Su'a William Sio gets a hug from Family First NZ member Steve McRobie after receiving the petition. Photo / Mark Mitchell

A bill to legalise gay marriage is expected to clear its historic first hurdle this evening, but the battle lines have been clearly drawn as lobby groups and a growing number of MPs declare their opposition.

Sixty-four MPs have said they will back the amendment to marriage legislation ahead of the first reading. It needs 61 votes to progress to a select committee.

Labour MP Louisa Wall, the bill's sponsor, made a final plea to opposing and fence-sitting MPs yesterday, saying the present law discriminated against same-sex and transgender couples.

"[A marriage licence] is the only licence you can't get if you're homosexual in New Zealand. I feel it's wrong and we need to make sure that we live in a just and equal society."

She had the backing of all but three of her caucus. Ross Robertson, Su'a William Sio and Damien O'Connor will vote "no" this evening.

Mr Robertson and Mr Sio were among a group of MPs who met conservative lobby group Family First on the steps of Parliament yesterday to accept a 48,000-strong petition calling for the bill to be scrapped.

New Zealand First was giving mixed messages about its voting intentions. But MP Brendan Horan suggested the party would oppose, not abstain.

"If there's a referendum in the bill, we'll support it. If not, I won't," he said.

Act Party leader John Banks confirmed he would vote for the bill at the first reading.

Mr Banks previously voted against Homosexual Law Reform and the Civil Union Bill. Asked why he was supporting it, he replied: "Because I am."

A large number of MPs have pledged their support to the first reading only, and their continued support depended on the debate at select committee. Among some concerns were how the law change would affect adoption rules and access to reproductive technology.

National MP Paul Hutchison, who opposed the bill, said: "We're in a situation where a gay individual can adopt, a gay couple cannot adopt. We haven't even talked about that kind of stuff and I think it's very important that we do."

Ms Wall said she hoped for an open, honest debate. "What I don't like is scaremongering and the fact that ministers are saying [they] will have to go to jail."

She was referring to a legal opinion from Family First which said church ministers and celebrants who refused to marry gay couples would be criminalised by the bill. This opinion went against a paper released last week by the Human Rights Commission.

Ms Wall: "They will retain all the rights that they currently have ...my bill isn't going to affect them in any way."

- NZ Herald

© Copyright 2014, APN New Zealand Limited

Assembled by: (static) on red akl_a2 at 23 Sep 2014 23:30:59 Processing Time: 989ms