Isaac Davison

Isaac Davison is a NZ Herald political reporter.

Same-sex law vote - Peters' new plan

A bill to legalise same-sex marriage is close to having the numbers to pass its first stage. File photo / Mark Mitchell
A bill to legalise same-sex marriage is close to having the numbers to pass its first stage. File photo / Mark Mitchell

A bill to legalise same-sex marriage is close to having the numbers to pass its first stage, despite an attempt by New Zealand First to derail it.

A Herald poll of all 121 MPs found 54 of them intend to vote for Labour Party MP Louisa Wall's private member's bill, which would redefine marriage as a union of two people, "regardless of their sex, sexual orientation or gender identity".

It was expected to be decided by a conscience vote, and needs 61 votes to pass.

But many MPs have refused to take a side on the contentious debate, and the final vote could be close.

New Zealand First yesterday complicated the process, with leader Winston Peters suggesting the party might abstain from the first vote - expected to take place in late August.

Mr Peters called for a referendum to be held on same-sex marriage.

"Serious issues like this should be decided by the public of this country, and not a few temporary, empowered politicians."

He would not give a direct answer when asked whether New Zealand First MPs would choose to abstain.

If the party did opt out, the bill would need only 57 votes to pass.

The Herald poll showed this number was well within reach.

But if New Zealand First did vote, its members are likely to oppose it.

One of the party's MPs, Richard Prosser, has previously said he would vote against it, and two others, Mr Peters and Barbara Stewart, voted against civil unions in 2004.

Five other MPs - National MPs Chester Borrows, Phil Heatley, Colin King, Eric Roy and Mike Sabin - say they would oppose a law change.

Mr Borrows said he had "faith-based reasons" for opposing the bill.

Mr King said: "What my wife and I have enjoyed over 42 years, I don't think anybody else of the same sex could enjoy."

All MPs from the Green Party, the Maori Party, Mana, United Future and most Labour MPs said they supported the bill at least at the first reading.

Eight National MPs, including Prime Minister John Key and Cabinet ministers Paula Bennett and Hekia Parata, have also backed the bill.

But because some Labour MPs were likely to vote against it - Clayton Cosgrove, Damien O'Connor and Ross Robertson did not vote for civil unions - a few more National votes would probably be needed to push the bill into the committee stage.

Thirty-seven National MPs have not made their mind up on the bill.

Most of them said they had not read it, or were seeking responses from their constituents.

National MP Shane Ardern said he was opposed only to churches being required to act against their beliefs - something Ms Wall has said would not happen.

"But if it's just a case of giving some kind of legal status that they don't already have, then I wouldn't oppose that," Mr Ardern said.

THE NUMBERS

Are you for or against Louisa Wall's bill?

* 52 - For
* 13 - Against
* 2 - Undecided / maybe for
* 2 - Undecided / maybe against
* 44 - Undecided
* 8 - No reply / no comment.

- NZ Herald

Your views

© Copyright 2014, APN New Zealand Limited

Assembled by: (static) on red akl_a4 at 19 Apr 2014 22:27:46 Processing Time: 697ms