Nicholas Jones

Nicholas Jones is the New Zealand Herald’s education reporter.

Vic knocks Auckland off its perch

Latest ranking of universities, based on the research performance of academic staff, puts Auckland in second.

Rival Victoria University of Wellington is now number one in New Zealand. Photo / Getty Images
Rival Victoria University of Wellington is now number one in New Zealand. Photo / Getty Images

The University of Auckland has been knocked off its perch in a ranking of universities on the research performance of academic staff.

Rival Victoria University of Wellington is now number one in New Zealand, according to the latest Performance-Based Research Fund (PBRF) Quality Evaluation, released yesterday by the Tertiary Education Commission (TEC).

The University of Auckland, which under current measures ranked first in both the 2003 and 2006 evaluations, ranked second. The PBRF is a system used to assess the research performance of tertiary education organisations.

Its results are used in the allocation of about $263 million a year in research funding.

The University of Otago ranked third, followed by the University of Canterbury, University of Waikato, Massey University, Lincoln University, Auckland University of Technology (AUT) and Unitec.

In releasing the rankings, the TEC noted that they did not represent the quality of a university, as other aspects such as teaching or course content were not measured.

Universities also vary in the quality across subject areas.

Yesterday, University of Auckland vice-chancellor Professor Stuart McCutcheon said its second-place ranking was "apparently counter-intuitive".

He said the PBRF had confirmed the university as the country's leading research institution.

It had secured the largest share of the fund, with $80.4 million or 30.6 per cent of the national total, reflecting its dominance in the three core components of the PBRF.

Mr McCutcheon said the change in rankings reflected a new method in calculation. For example, the postgraduate component divided the quality parameter by the number of postgraduate students enrolled - which had disadvantaged Auckland because it had grown its programme.

"We are interested in the productivity of the university by international standards, and so the average quality score is not a big issue as far as we are concerned."

AUT vice-chancellor Derek McCormack said because the rankings were based on average scores they were "spurious".

He said that despite maintaining its ranking of eighth, AUT had more than doubled its funding and research-active staff in the latest round.


Tertiary research

2012 Quality Evaluation ranking:

1. Victoria University

2. University of Auckland

3. University of Otago

4. University of Canterbury

5. University of Waikato

6. Massey University

7. Lincoln University

8. Auckland University of Technology

9. Unitec

Source: The Tertiary Education Commission.

- NZ Herald

© Copyright 2014, APN New Zealand Limited

Assembled by: (static) on production apcf02 at 23 Nov 2014 22:14:04 Processing Time: 396ms