nzherald.co.nz

Inside Money: Choice moments in KiwiSaver month

By David Chaplin
9:30 AM Thursday Feb 28, 2013
Photo / NZ Herald

Photo / NZ Herald

February must have been KiwiSaver Action Month.

As well as the long-awaited sale of Tower to Fisher Funds (something of an anti-climax when the official news was announced), February saw:

The long-awaited decision to merge the Axa and AMP schemes;

ASB giving up on active management (its main KiwiSaver scheme, the popular one, invests by the index) as it shut the doors on its almost-forgotten FirstChoice scheme;

The Warren Couillault (formerly of Fisher Funds) KiwiSaver venture, Generate, revealing its underlying hedge fund-of-funds strategies.

In other news, Fidelity also formally launched a couple of extra options on its KiwiSaver menu. The two new funds were actually added to the Fidelity list in November (along with another life-cycle option called Life Phases) and provide an interesting first for KiwiSaver investors.

The two products, the Asset Class Conservative Kiwi and Asset Class Growth Kiwi funds, will be managed by Dimensional Fund Advisors, a name probably not familiar to many retail investors.

Dimensional was founded by some Nobel Prize-class boffins in the early 1980s and, to date, has only been available via financial advisers or institutional-style investments.

The US-based manager also prides itself on never paying product commissions, and hence deals only with fee-based financial planners.

Normally, access to investing with Dimensional in New Zealand is restricted to a select number of accredited financial advisers and institutions, a launch press release explains, however, the Fidelity KiwiSaver Scheme now allows KiwiSaver members the opportunity to utilise the Dimensional investment approach.

Interestingly, the Dimensional funds have been brought to the KiwiSaver table by Hastings-based financial adviser, Nick Stewart, who will act as asset consultant/adviser for the Asset Class products under the newly-formed entity, Stewart Group Asset Management.

So while consolidation occurs apace at the big end of town (Fisher/Tower, AMP/Axa etc) the fact that offerings as opposed as Generate and Dimensional are willing to give KiwiSaver a go is positive for fans of investment choice.

By David Chaplin
KiwiCoastal (Thames) | 09:39AM Friday, 01 Mar 2013
I was going to join Gareth Morgan, but then he turned into a nutcase on cats and I thought he might be a nutcase with my money too, so instead I just joined another Kiwisaver scheme. Interestingly, they said they had gained a few new customers who had swtiched from GM to them as a result of the anti cat thing...It certainly help me rule GM out...
Anonymous opinion (Auckland Central) | 09:39AM Friday, 01 Mar 2013
It would be really nice to see some new funds with providers allowing savvy Kiwisavers to invest by sector or geographical location. So far for every fund I am aware of, we are left guessing as to where our money is being invested (except for being told it is in "cash", "bonds" or "equities".) Does not give me much control of my own destiny or any opportunity to get ahead of the common man.
Old fashioned and conservative () | 09:40AM Friday, 01 Mar 2013
As the Mainzeal creditors are no doubt aware, directors should be judged by performance rather than by the accolades they have received in the past. The Dimensional fund has one 1980s Nobel Laureate (Economics) remaining on its board. Its Australian fund annual report (available on the internet) indicates some 48 million dollars were earned in 2012 with about 7% of earnings going in fees, of that only $140000 as brokerage- as might be expected for a static investor.

Kiwisaver funds are intrinsically long term investments, and the only way to tell if this fund will predict the future better than another is by waiting that long term to see if the fund still exists, whether it will still attract Nobel Laureates to its board, and whether its choices really were better than the common funds.
Copyright ©2013, APN Holdings NZ Limited