nzherald.co.nz

Editorial: Another year of sporting excellence to savour

5:30 AM Wednesday Dec 26, 2012
The All Blacks lost a few players, but there was absolutely no let-up in their standard or intensity. Photo / APN

The All Blacks lost a few players, but there was absolutely no let-up in their standard or intensity. Photo / APN

After the lord mayor's show, it is said, comes the dust-cart. On that basis, New Zealanders approached this sporting year with some trepidation. 2011 had been a halcyon 12 months, highlighted by victory at the rugby World Cup, a test cricket win in Australia, and the Breakers' breakthrough triumph in an Australian club competition. After all those glittering and long-sought prizes, could the only way be down?

As it transpired, there was no need to worry. This year was, in many ways, the equal of its predecessor. The All Blacks went from strength to strength, a final hiccup against England at Twickenham notwithstanding, the Breakers repeated their feat and were joined by the Waikato Bay of Plenty Magic netball team, a rare test victory was achieved by the Black Caps in Sri Lanka, 15-year-old Lydia Ko emerged as a golfing phenomenon and, best of all, New Zealand enjoyed arguably its most successful Olympics.

World Cup-winning rugby teams have made a habit of letting their standards slip in the year following their victory. Inevitably, some players retire, and there is a sense of let-down after the ultimate triumph.

The All Blacks lost a few players, perhaps most notably Jerome Kaino and, eventually, Sonny Bill Williams, but there was absolutely no let-up in their standard or intensity. The introduction of a new coach, Steve Hansen, and some exciting young players played a key role as the All Blacks comfortably won the new Rugby Championship and went undefeated for 20 tests. The stumble against England and an earlier draw with Australia were sharp reminders, however, of the dangers of complacency, fatigue and occasional frailty among the forwards.

The excellence of the All Blacks was matched by key members of the London Olympics team. A haul of 13 medals - six golds, two silvers and five bronzes - spoke volumes of sports people making light of the often significant gulf between themselves and their rivals in financial support and training facilities. In a rowing team that won three golds and two bronzes, Hamish Bond and Eric Murray were boat lengths better than their nearest rivals, and Mahe Drysdale finally confirmed his status as the world's best single sculler. The task for rowing now is to meet the high level of expectation that will accompany it to the Rio Olympics.

London also unveiled a new star in canoeist Lisa Carrington. The manner in which her gold medal was achieved and celebrated was astounding for one relatively new to sport at the highest level.

The story of the Games for New Zealand, however, was that of Valerie Adams. She confirmed her standing as the world's best female shot putter but only after tasting unexpected defeat on the day of competition. Suspicions about the performance of Nadzeya Ostapchuk soon proved well founded when she was declared a drugs cheat. Somehow, Adams' gold seemed all the sweeter.

The year did, as usual, have its share of disappointments. The All Whites' apparently straightforward route to the Confederations Cup evaporated in the heat of the Pacific. High hopes were also held for the Warriors under new coach Brian McClennan. They failed to come to fruition and he was gone before the end of the rugby league season.

But no fall was as dramatic, or as undeserved, as that of Ross Taylor from the captaincy of the Black Caps. Having just orchestrated test success in Sri Lanka, he was axed for no discernible reason and in a manner that cast doubt on the ability and integrity of those running the game. It was a sour note on which to end a year of so much success.

Bruce C (Queensland) | 06:52PM Friday, 28 Dec 2012
Pretty short list really, you'll just have to eat your rugby.
exgus (New Zealand) | 06:52PM Friday, 28 Dec 2012
It was definitely a successful year. The events around Valerie Adams and the All Blacks highlights the fact that sometimes the public forget that all our athletes/players are human beings, however gifted. We are sometimes under the illusion that success just happens because of God given talent or that money has been thrown at it.
Valerie Adams was upset more for not performing at her best rather than not winning. She'd been affected by mistakes made by Athletics NZ. But let us not forget that administrators are also human beings who have sacrificed countless hours to make things happen. And yes, mistakes can be made.
The All Blacks fell at the final hurdle and the mean spirited among us suddenly start drawing the daggers. Success is taken for granted mostly by people who do nothing but pontificate in their armchairs - those boys in black are extremely talented, well paid, but at the end of the day they are just boys, like your son, your brother who have worked extremely hard to be as good as they are.
Merry Christmas, enjoy the success when it happens and be sympathetic when it doesn't.
YouKNOWItsTheTruth (New Zealand) | 06:52PM Friday, 28 Dec 2012
Sporting excellence? We do well in a few sports that nobody else in the world plays (rugby, league, netball), and are average at the Olympics.

We don't "punch above our weight" or do well given the size of our population, because winning medals isn't just a function of how many people a country has. If it were, India should win 20% of Olympic medals. Winning medals is about money, geography, politics, genetics, culture and all sorts of other factors.

There are rarely any white or Asian sprinters in the Olympics 100m final because of genetics. Not many Africans win medals at the winter Olympics due to geography. Not many Muslim women win medals due to religion. Not many Syrians win medals due to politics.

We win our medals in relatively unpopular and elitest sports (rowing, equestrian) or sports that suit our lifestyle and culture. Lisa Carrington, for example, is good at rowing because she has done surf-lifesaving in Whakatane since she was a child. People in Manchester and New York don't grow up in that environment, so of course we are likely to do well in that sport.

These are the things that dictate how many medals we win. It isn't that we're special. Sorry.
Copyright ©2013, APN Holdings NZ Limited