nzherald.co.nz

Winston Aldworth: Running the numbers

By Winston Aldworth @WinstonAldworth
9:30 AM Tuesday Dec 11, 2012
 Photo / Thinkstock

Photo / Thinkstock

I'm trying to figure out the formula behind our decision-making when considering a flight on a budget airline.

So far, the algorithm looks something like this: X - Y รท Z = A.

X, of course, is the money saved. Y represents the perceived chance of inconvenience (will the flight be late? Will the plane get diverted?), while Z is customer satisfaction (do you get a patriotic buzz from seeing hobbits in the safety video?).

I'm lousy at maths, but I know the value of a buck. When planning our family's flight to Queenstown to visit the in-laws for Christmas, there was a $400 difference between Air New Zealand and Jetstar.

That's the X-factor.

For me, there's a prominent Y-factor. A couple of years ago, when flying into Queenstown with Jetstar, we got diverted to Invercargill because of fog. From there, we had a three-hour bus ride to Queenstown - an unexpected journey, indeed.

Colin Hogg's excellent series on New Zealand's "Hidden Gems" sang the praises of Invercargill a fortnight ago and having lived there years ago, I was curious to see how the old town was looking. But wouldn't you know it, the bus actually bypassed the centre of the city instead zipping through some run-down streets alongside the railway.

Jetstar have since fitted-out their fleet with electronics that would have allowed us to land in Queenstown. But, given their recent bad press on cancelled flights, it says much for the power of the dollar - the X-factor - that we opted for Jetstar again.

By Winston Aldworth @WinstonAldworth
OutOfThis () | 10:26AM Tuesday, 11 Dec 2012
Bad, bad, bad decision... (but it's your choice) I don't have indefinite amounts of money but I'd always go Air New Zealand. I flew Jetstar return ONCE, and had an awful experience both flights. They've done nothing to win my custom. I feel soiled.
JD (New Zealand) | 10:33AM Tuesday, 11 Dec 2012
If it doesnt matter if you get there, late, diverted, or at all, then budget would be the way to go. But if you have to be at your destination by a certain day/time, and especially if in transit for a connecting flight, then never go for budget
Paihinu (Otago) | 10:38AM Tuesday, 11 Dec 2012
Jetstar service (an oxymoron) reminds me of Yes Minister and the hospital that had no patients because they would just get in the way. Air NZ is my choice every time, and my wife's even though she has a high-level Qantas frequent flyer card - yes, Jetstar is just Qantas under another name. But Air NZ needs a brickbat too - since Jetstar abandoned the Queenstown-Christchurch route the fares on Air NZ for that 45 min trip have become diabolical. Might be cheaper to do Queenstown-Sydney-Christchurch - except that would be Jetstar!
Copyright ©2013, APN Holdings NZ Limited