Gregor Paul: Fouls tally calls for scrutiny

9:30 AM Thursday Nov 29, 2012

Andrew Hore's actions in the Wales test provoked the latest in a slew of citings against southern players. Photo / Getty Images

Rugby's rule book is open to interpretation which may explain why this month eight players from the Southern Hemisphere have been cited for foul play while not one from the north has.

Discipline, or lack of, has become a prevailing theme throughout the autumn tests and of all the statistics to emerge in the past few weeks, this landslide victory to the Southern Hemisphere is easily the most interesting for it generates an environment for conspiracies to breed.

The All Blacks are at the epicentre of the storm. The actions of Adam Thomson and Andrew Hore have only added weight to the widely held perception of the All Blacks as thugs - an image they may never shake.

But is the tail wagging the dog? When was the last time the All Blacks had a player cited before Thomson?

It was Keven Mealamu, playing against England in London two years ago. Before that? Daniel Carter playing against Wales in Cardiff in 2009.

Rarely in the past five years have All Blacks been cited when they have played in the Southern Hemisphere. Discipline has only been an issue when they have come to Europe.

How to explain that? Are the Northern Hemisphere sides just a bit soft - protected by a zealous judiciary who keep forgetting it is not tiddlywinks? Or is rugby in the Southern Hemisphere a little edgier, full of rough diamonds and blue collars who feel eggs have to be broken to make omelettes? Or, more sinister yet, has the overwhelming dominance of Southern Hemisphere nations in the past five years resulted in their Northern Hemisphere opponents having become avid trawlers of video footage in the hope they can find some dirt to throw?

It seems odd, a huge anomaly, that the Rugby Championship and its Tri Nations predecessor threw up only occasional and isolated incidents of foul play and now, in the space of three weeks, the judiciary has been crammed with supposed Southern Hemisphere thugs.

Thomson and Hore have been joined in the dock by, among others, South Africa's Eben Etzebeth and Australia's Rob Simmons and Sitaleki Timani. Tonga, Samoa and Argentina have also had to attend hearings.

No one who follows Super rugby and the Rugby Championship would argue that the game in the Southern Hemisphere is riddled with filth.

There are incidents; there are unsavoury moments and ill-timed and clumsy tackles and cleanouts and the like: but consistent cheap shots ... no, not from any international side, especially not now Bakkies Botha has moved on.

Strangely, the same couldn't be said of the game in Europe, where eye-gouging appears to be endemic; where this year England captain Dylan Hartley was cited for biting.

Just as odd, if not more so, than the excessive citings of the Southern Hemisphere players is the non-citing of any from the North - England especially have a poor track record in recent times, with Danny Grewcock, Hartley and Chris Ashton all well known to the judiciary.

It is impossible to have rational debate on this issue, but it is needed: the statistics of the past few weeks paint an alarming picture - one that is hard to fit in with the prevailing trends.

Mickey Mouse () | 10:00AM Thursday, 29 Nov 2012

Good to see actual statistics quoted, Gregor, on the number of complaints against the AB's in the last few years. There has been considerable hyperbole from another sports writer about the AB's being thugs, which is absolute garbage. Rugby is a hard physical game but there is no need for illegal play and with cameras from every angle recording every movement players a very aware they cannot get away with anything and in fact quite often the resultant replay shows an innocent mistake. Well written and researched article Gregor.

Old Dog (Hokianga) | 10:00AM Thursday, 29 Nov 2012

The count is not high in my view in terms of Pacific teams playing with their usual passion in a couple of dozen tests.

None of the SH teams think test rugby is tiddlywinks and do play up to the edge. Mostly but not always with the required discipline.

I cannot offhand recall a NH offence that was ignored.

Both Thompson and Hore full yearned their citings, as did Simmons and the Samoan tip tackle (although it was merely technical and at the light end).

I did not see any of the other incidents cited, but there seems plenty of evidence the SH teams are pretty keen in their defence.

Observer (New Zealand) | 10:00AM Thursday, 29 Nov 2012

It is simple to understand.

The Southern teams are better teams than the Northern, win more games and play harder rugby. Northern teams watch too much soccer (or to use their term "Football" - yea another Tui please) and the black shirted bloke who appears to have been trained in the Berlin bunker in the 40's, and use the media who believe that what they say is God decreed, as a means to deplete the firepower that the Southern teams bring North.

What is needed are better simpler rules in rugby (some as per the EVA's that got kicked out) and the IRB HQ to come South to be administered here.

The inconsistancy of punishments between "weeks" and "games", and attack on players like McCaw by thugs who get only two weeks (not games) needs addressing.
Gregor is on the right track but is like most shouting into a screaming Nor'West wind.