nzherald.co.nz

Gregor Paul: Just one more big push to be Player of Year

By Gregor Paul
5:30 AM Tuesday Nov 27, 2012
Richie McCaw. Photo / Getty Images

Richie McCaw. Photo / Getty Images

With his six-month sabbatical looming, the influence of Richie McCaw this week is likely to be more intense than normal. The All Black skipper won't want to sign off with anything other than a victory at Twickenham.

He may also have an extra incentive in that one more big effort individually will see him sign off as the IRB Player of the Year for the fourth time.

The six-man shortlist will shortly be revealed and the credibility of the award will nose-dive if McCaw is not on it and dip significantly if he doesn't win it. The question for the judges is can they really convince themselves that there has been a better, more consistent, more influential player in world rugby this year than McCaw?

There have been some seriously good contenders. Juan Martin Fernandez Lobbe has been dynamic, inspirational and, frankly, a class act all season. He has to be on the short-list. Kieran Read has been superb as well - a bruising ball-carrier, perpetual motion and fearless.

He has to be there.

Bryan Habana delivered emphatic proof he can still score tries and make something out of nothing, while continuing with his immaculate defence and kick-chase game.

George North, Dan Lydiate and Leigh Halfpenny were integral components of Wales' Grand Slam campaign, Nathan Sharpe defied his age and played better than he ever has and then there are a handful of All Blacks such as Cory Jane, Daniel Carter, Israel Dagg, Conrad Smith and Tony Woodcock who have been consistently good at the highest level.

But was anyone actually consistently better than McCaw in 2012?

By Gregor Paul
adbee (New Zealand) | 12:42PM Tuesday, 27 Nov 2012
"But was anyone actually consistently better than McCaw in 2012?"

No.
Sheelagh (New Zealand) | 12:43PM Tuesday, 27 Nov 2012
A true all round sportsman. Could teach his teammate Andrew Hore, a lot about the privilege of being an All Black.
Realist (Takapuna) | 03:20PM Tuesday, 27 Nov 2012
Richie is just AWESOME!! The best rugby player I have ever seen - not only the greatest in his position but also the greatest captain and All Black of all time. He is a role model for all New Zealanders and rugby players the world over. The person I would most like to meet. Richie for president!
Copyright ©2013, APN Holdings NZ Limited