nzherald.co.nz

Papa Don't Preach: 'NZers are an intolerant bunch of child haters'

By Scott Kara @scottkara
10:10 AM Wednesday Jun 20, 2012
Many New Zealanders are intolerant of children, says Scott Kara. 
Photo / Thinkstock

Many New Zealanders are intolerant of children, says Scott Kara. Photo / Thinkstock

Last week I wrote about the rigours of keeping your children under control when you are out and about. Turns out, it's a divisive and touchy subject.

And little did I know that many New Zealanders are an intolerant bunch of child haters. That might sound harsh, but given the number of respondents who were, what can only be described as anti-kids, then it's warranted.

There were some empathetic parents who offered their own tips on how best to amuse your little ones at a restaurant or on the plane. But much of the feedback was from people who wanted children to be kept under wraps until they are old enough to be obedient (the dog analogy is intentional) and know their place.

There were comments like, why bother taking kids on holiday since they aren't old enough to remember anything anyway? My simple answer to that is, because their grandparents would hardly see them otherwise. And then there was the person who demanded I keep my "screaming kids away from adult restaurants".

Not sure I've seen a "no children allowed sign" outside any restaurants lately. And besides, as I pointed out last week, my wife and I always take the kids out early so we have finished by the time the busy period hits.

And some insisted my wife and I "get a baby sitter". If only, because they don't come cheap these days and we don't have many family in town to call on to help out. However, a babysitter is beside the point because if we want to go out for dinner as a family then why shouldn't we?

Yes, out of control kids can make a restaurant or a plane flight unpleasant - sometimes downright intolerable - for other members of the public. But we - like most parents - want our kids to be social and outgoing and the only way to teach them that is to take them out and about.

Also, given this sort of intolerance it's no wonder there is a high rate of child abuse in New Zealand society. Not to mention the impact this sort of negativity and aversion to children has on Kiwi kids' self esteem and social skills.

Like most parents, my own kids drive me nuts on regular occasions, whether it's Mia not shutting up about the latest bee that she's got in her bonnet. Or when Katie breaks down after I take a pen off her (because she's at the age where drawing on walls is fun). But they are kids, that's what they do until you teach them right from wrong.

Which is why, as I also pointed out last week, keeping children under control is first and foremost a parent's responsibility. So take it easy on the kids would you.


Debate on this article is now closed.

By Scott Kara @scottkara
Thales (Auckland Central) | 10:56AM Wednesday, 20 Jun 2012
'New Zealanders are an intolerant bunch of child haters'
One thing I've noticed lately is that columnists are using more and more emotionally charged words and phrasing. I know that it means more people will visit your site and leave comments but I think it's really sad that any potential discussion is being ruined from the onset. You've set up a piece precisely so a group of people can leave comments venting their outrage. What's the point?
h m () | 11:14AM Wednesday, 20 Jun 2012
Comments about keeping kids under control in public areas are compared with child abusers? Right.
Auckgirl (Auckland Region) | 11:14AM Wednesday, 20 Jun 2012
Ouch! I am sorry but I do NOT agree with you on this. I am childless (and happy) and while I enjoy contact with other peoples kids from time to time in the right context, I do not want to go out to a nice restaurant or a movie and have my experience ruined by people who bring kids who are too young there.

If you have kids you have to accept the fact that you have to make sacrifices eg getting a babysitter, going to MCDs instead or a family friendly restaurant instead. Have some consideration for those of us who want a quiet meal out and do not want to have it wrecked by noisy, out of control kids who should not be there.

Maybe you could have been better prepared for the night out and had some activities to keep her occupied until the meal arrived. Letting her wander around a restaurant at will disturbing diners is selfish as well. You are complaining about not be able to afford a babysitter or get family to babysit. Well you chose to have kids so you chose the consequence of that and you need to adapt your lifestyle accordingly.
Copyright ©2013, APN Holdings NZ Limited