nzherald.co.nz

Trailer for Madonna's royal scandal flick W.E. debuts (+video)

By Myrddin Gwynedd @ohthatwelshguy
11:00 AM Friday Nov 25, 2011

Madonna isn't a name that's synonymous with movie magic, so it's no great surprise that her latest directorial effort has had a critical mauling.

Madge's semi-historical drama W.E. received a barrage of scathing reviews when it debuted at the Venice Film Festival back in September.

"The script is the first problem. Co-written with Alek Keshishian, it's laden with cliches and clunky exposition from the off, with some moments drawing laughs from the Venice audience," cried The Playlist's Oliver Lyttelton.

The Guardian's Xan Brooks sniped: "What an extraordinarily silly, preening, fatally mishandled film this is.

"Her direction is so all over the shop that it barely qualifies as direction at all. W.E. gives us slo-mo and jump cuts and a crawling crane shot up a tree in Balmoral, but they are all just tricks without a purpose."

Not that her Madgesty will give a loathsome hydrangea what the critics think.

"I know that I did the best that I could do," the Hung Up singer told indieWIRE.

"I pay attention to reviews where I know people are reviewing my work. When they're letting me, the person, the human being, get in the way, then I don't really give it much credence. At the end of the day, I made the film to be judged as a film. Not for people to compare it to me."

She added, "I understand that that's going to happen. I knew going into this that people were going to sometimes get their opinion of me mixed up and muddled in with my work. So of course I always appreciate it when people really review my film and stick to the film."

Starring James D'Arcy as King Edward VIII and Andrea Riseborough as his twice-divorced American lover Wallis Simpson (for whom he abdicated his throne for in 1936), the movie focuses on Wally Winthrop, played by Abbie Cornish, and her obsession with the royal and his taboo relationship.

So has the former lady of perpetual commotion really got a free range celluloid turkey on her hands?

Check out the trailer below and judge for yourselves:

W.E. opens on December 9 in New York and Los Angeles, and on January 23 in the UK.

- Blogger Bites Back

By Myrddin Gwynedd @ohthatwelshguy
Kiwi Guy (New Zealand) | 10:37AM Friday, 25 Nov 2011
Turkey. Madonna needs to stop making movies, she has never had the talent for it. And she needs to stop making music, she is too old, her time has passed.
jack fitsgerald () | 10:09AM Sunday, 27 Nov 2011
30 years into her career and the tabloids are still making money out of her creative endeavours. I wouldnt exactly say her time as passed, if anything the world is still as obsessed by this remarkable woman as they were nearly 30 years ago.

And if her minions of clones currently sweeping the pop world are anything to go by (GaGa, Britney, Kylie, Rihanna). Then I'd say it is she who has had the last laugh, Madonna may not live for ever, but her legacy obviously will, and what better way to outlast your critics than through the very people she inspired.
Terryjackson1nyc () | 10:09AM Sunday, 27 Nov 2011
I understand that some of the reviews were awful, but some of them were also quite great. Pointing out the former certainly helps paint a picture, but including some of the latter would make for a better story, if only because we're talking about something real. You're only telling the half that suits your interests, not the full story that suits the interests of all readers, who are probably looking for truth above all else.
Copyright ©2013, APN Holdings NZ Limited